SD/044 PfSH L1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment Part 1 Appendix A
Summary
Document Viewer
Partnership for South Hampshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note Fluvial River Floodplain Analysis
Project number: 60653132
Technical Note
- Project number
- 60653132
- Project (Client)
- Partnership for South Hampshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (Portsmouth City Council)
- Subject
- Fluvial River Floodplain Analysis
- Prepared by
-
Phoebe Ruddock, Graduate Engineer — Date: 31st March 2022
Simon Buckley, Principal Consultant - Checked by
- Sarah Littlewood, Principal Consultant — Date: 5th April 2022
- Verified by
- Helen Judd, Associate — Date: 12th May 2022
- Version
-
Version 1.1 Draft for Comment — Date: May 2022
Version 1.2 Minor Revisions — Date: August 2023
Version 1.3 Minor Revisions — Date: November 2023
1. Introduction
1.1 Overview
Guidance for the preparation of Strategic Flood Risk Assessments (SFRAs)1 in England states that a Level 1 SFRA should include maps of the ‘expected effects of climate change’.
For some of the fluvial watercourses in the Partnership for South Hampshire (PfSH) SFRA study area, modelled flood extents including the expected impacts of climate change are available from catchment scale hydraulic models held by the Environment Agency. However, for a large number of fluvial watercourses in the study area, available information on the risk of flooding is limited to JFLOW flood zones. JFLOW applies a generalised methodology and simplified assumptions to produce national datasets of Flood Zone 2 (0.1% (1 in 1000 year) Annual Exceedance Probability (AEP)) and Flood Zone 3 (1% AEP (1 in 100 year)), but no additional outputs regarding the impact of climate change.
It is not achievable to develop catchment scale hydraulic models for all the watercourses within the PfSH SFRA study area. Where there is little growth and development proposed by LPAs, there is little justification for such work.
On the other hand, there are some watercourses where the Environment Agency have commenced work to develop catchment scale hydraulic models, but the outputs are not available for this issue of the SFRA. For example, the River Test and the Monk’s Brook which are currently being surveyed prior to the development of hydraulic models. Outputs from these studies will need to be incorporated into future iterations of the SFRA.
In the meantime, to inform this version of the PfSH SFRA, GIS analysis has been undertaken to help identify those areas of fluvial floodplain that may be sensitive to increases in flood levels. The GIS analysis uses a LiDAR digital terrain model (DTM) to identify the water levels along the edge of the Flood Map for Planning Flood Zone 3 extent. Additional flood extents have then been generated by increasing the water levels by pre-defined amounts and comparing the newly created water surfaces with the LiDAR DTM.
This analysis does not map the anticipated impacts of climate change and is not a substitute for hydraulic modelling. However, it does identify those areas of floodplain which could be sensitive to increases in flood levels. This provides a useful indication to LPAs for where additional modelling may be required in the future, should these areas be considered for future growth or development.
1 Environment Agency, March 2022. How to prepare a strategic flood risk assessment. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/local-planning-authorities-strategic-flood-risk-assessment
Partnership for South Hampshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note Fluvial River Floodplain Analysis
Project number: 60653132
2. Fluvial River Floodplain Analysis Methodology
2.1 Study Area
For the purposes of this Fluvial River Floodplain Analysis, the PfSH study area has been divided into five regions based upon broad characteristics of the river catchments, as shown in Figure 2-1.
Figure 2-1 PfSH GIS Floodplain Analysis Study Areas
2.2 Software
The GIS analysis was undertaken using ArcGIS Pro 2.9.
2.3 Input Data
Table 2-1 identifies the datasets used within the GIS analysis.
Table 2-1 Input datasets
| Dataset | Description |
|---|---|
| Digital Terrain Model | 2m resolution DTM obtained in .asc format from the Defra Data Services Platform. This provides suitable coverage and resolution for the chosen approach. |
| EA Flood Zones | Environment Agency Flood Zones 2 and 3 in .shp file format from the Defra Data Services Platform |
| Detailed River Network | DRN layer supplied to AECOM in .shp file format |
| LPA Boundaries | PfSH Local Authority Area boundaries supplied in .shp file format |
| OS Land Boundary | England land boundary obtained in .shp file format |
2.4 Data Pre-processing
Prior to completion of the GIS analysis, the individual 2m LiDAR DTM tiles were joined to create a continuous mosaic (referred to hereafter as the LiDAR DTM).
The Flood Map for Planning Flood Zone 2 and Flood Zone 3 GIS layers were obtained and a 500m buffer applied to the polygons. The output layers will be referred to as flood zone buffers.
The LIDAR DTM and flood zone buffers were added to a GIS workspace alongside the other datasets included in Table 2-1 Input datasets. A 2,000m buffer was applied around each study area region and the analysis was applied within this region. The outputs were cropped to the actual study area after all flood zones has been created. This ensured there were no edge effects and all data appropriately joined up between regions.
2.5 Method
The Fluvial River Floodplain GIS Analysis involved six key steps, detailed below and summarised in Figure 2-2.
Step 1- Create Flood Zone extent points and assign elevations
- Points were created at equal 50m intervals along the boundaries of the Flood Zone polygons.
-
Manual editing was undertaken to remove:
- Points far away from the main flood zone corresponding to very small detached flooded areas, ensuring a water surface was not interpolated from the main flood zone to these points, and
- Points corresponding to tidal flooding in coastal areas; this analysis is based on the recreation of fluvial flooding only. In areas where flood extents could not clearly be established as from tidal flooding only, flood extents were retained.
- Elevations for the boundary points were extracted from the LiDAR DTM, with these elevations assumed to coincide with the maximum flood level for the 1% AEP event (Flood Zone 3) and 0.1% AEP event (Flood Zone 2).
Step 2- Create estimated water level surface
- An estimated water level surface for the 1% AEP event (Flood Zone 3) and 0.1% AEP event (Flood Zone 2) were generated through ‘natural neighbour’ interpolation using the point elevations generated in Step 1.
- The estimated water level surface was created with a 2m grid resolution, to match the LIDAR DTM.
- The estimated water level surface was visually inspected to identify discontinuities in the estimated water level surface, likely resulting from inaccurate LiDAR elevations. Where discontinuities were identified the point layer was edited to remove points where LiDAR was considered inaccurate.
Step 3- Create estimated depth grid
- An estimated flood depth grid for the 1% AEP event (Flood Zone 3) and 0.1% AEP event (Flood Zone 2) was created through subtracting the LIDAR DTM from the estimated water level surfaces generated in Step 2.
- The output grid had a resolution of 2m, in line with the LiDAR DTM and estimated flood level surfaces.
Step 4- Create final flood extent polygons
- The estimated depth grids for the 1% AEP event (Flood Zone 3) and 0.1% AEP event (Flood Zone 2), produced in Step 3, were used to create a binary flood extent raster grid. Within this grid flooded areas where assigned a value of 1 and not flooded areas a value of 0.
- The binary raster grid was subsequently converted into a flood extent polygon, depicting the predicted flood extent.
- The 500m buffer zone, generated within the pre-processing step, was applied in order to remove areas shown as flooded that were located more than 500m away from the flood zone. This typically removed areas of low lying topography remote from any watercourses that were errantly shown as being flooded, from the flood extent polygon.
- The flood zones were clipped to each actual study area at this stage, as stated in Section 2.4.
- The areas considered attributed to tidal flooding, for which points were deleted in Step 1, were removed from the generated flood extents.
Step 5- Accuracy Assessment
- In order to verify the methodology applied, basic qualitative accuracy assessment and sense checking was carried out on the outputs generated from Steps 1-4.
- The flood extent polygons generated for the 1% AEP event (Flood Zone 3) and 0.1% AEP event (Flood Zone 2) were overlain with the original flood zones and compared to ensure that they were acceptably reproduced. This check provided confidence in the processing methodology adopted, prior to completion of step 6.
-
Manual editing was undertaken to remove:
- Flood extents located where fluvial flood inundation was not considered possible, for example in low lying areas clearly disconnected from watercourses by topography or features such as roads and railway lines, and
- Flood extents that extended the floodplain horizontally, i.e., extended it beyond the original modelled length of the watercourse.
Step 6- Create vertically buffered flood extents
- In order to create vertically buffered flood extents, the point elevations extracted from the LIDAR DTM for Flood Zone 3 (1% AEP) in Step 1 were increased by 300mm and 600mm.
- Steps 2-5 were then repeated using the Flood Zone 3 water level points, with additional elevations included.
- Overall, this resulted in the production of predicted flood extents that would occur if water levels were to increase uniformly across the floodplain by 300mm and 600mm.
It is important to note that the increases in flood level of 300mm and 600mm do not correspond to a specific future climate change allowance. Rather, they have been selected in order to demonstrate a range of potential future change in water levels and to identify areas where the floodplain may be sensitive to such a change.
2.6 Post-processing
The flood extent outputs from the analysis were cleaned using a flood outline cleaning GIS routine. This routine fills small gaps present in order to create a more consistent extent.
Figure 2-2 Methodology Flowchart
Partnership for South Hampshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note Fluvial River Floodplain Analysis
Project number: 60653132
3. Results
3.1 Outputs
Vertically buffered flood extents produced through application of the methodology detailed in Section 2 are displayed in the Level 1 SFRA mapping for each of the LPAs.
3.2 Flood Zone Comparison
Figures 3-1 to 3-3 show comparisons between the Flood Map for Planning Flood Zone 3 and the 1% AEP flood extent created through application of the methodology detailed in Section 2.
It can be seen that in general the methodology applied represents Flood Zone 3 relatively well.
There are a number of areas created in the generated flood extent that are not present in the Flood Map for Planning Flood Zone. Where these areas are present in Figures 3-1 to 3-3, there was not enough evidence to suggest water would not flow here, for example if a flow path was blocked by high ground. This may be due to the updated DTM LiDAR information used in this analysis compared to what would have been used to create the Flood Map for Planning Flood Zones, or it may be due to inaccuracies in the methodology. This Fluvial River Floodplain GIS Analysis was undertaken in the absence of available hydraulic models, as a way to identify locations that may be sensitive to increase in flood levels based on an understanding of the relative ground levels. It is not expected to be as accurate as a model or a substitute for a model.
It can be seen from Figure 3-3 that the majority of the flooding in the Gosport BC, Portsmouth CC, and Havant BC administrative areas is considered to be tidal, or tidally influenced, and therefore not relevant to this analysis.
Figure 3-3 also shows that the generated flood zone significantly overpredicts the Flood Map for Planning Flood Zone in several locations within the Havant study area close to the coast. The land is relatively flat and low lying here, making the methodology less effective. On the other hand, further from the coast in the Winchester CC and Test Valley BC administrative areas, where the watercourses flow through more well defined valleys, the analysis produces more representative results.
Figure 3-2 Flood Zone Comparison 1
Figure 3-1 Flood Zone Comparison 2
Figure 3-3 Flood Zone Comparison 3
3.3 Key Limitations
The Fluvial River Floodplain GIS Analysis estimates flood levels based upon Flood Map for Planning Flood Zones and LiDAR data and generates new ‘vertically buffered’ flood extents assuming a fixed increase in flood level across the study catchment. The outputs from this GIS Floodplain Analysis are simplified and do not take into account the complex hydraulic processes and flooding mechanisms that would actually take place when flows are increased in the watercourses.
It is recommended that outputs from the Fluvial River Floodplain GIS Analysis (the ‘vertically buffered’ flood extents) should only be used to provide an indication of low lying areas adjacent to the existing floodplain that could be sensitive to changes in flood levels.
The outputs from the Fluvial River Floodplain GIS Analysis should not be used as a substitute for hydraulic modelling to quantify flood risk to and from a development. Site specific hydraulic modelling may be required to inform a Flood Risk Assessment (FRA). Refer to SFRA Part 1 Section 5.1.
Partnership for South Hampshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note Fluvial River Floodplain Analysis
Project number: 60653132
4. Summary
Hydraulic models identifying the ‘expected effects of climate change’ are not available for every watercourse in the PfSH SFRA study area. For some areas, little growth is anticipated and in other locations, there are hydraulic models under development as part of the Environment Agency’s programme of flood modelling studies (for example the River Test, Monk’s Brook).
As part of the PfSH SFRA, Fluvial River Floodplain GIS Analysis has been undertaken using Flood Zone 3 and LiDAR DTM to identify areas of floodplain that may be sensitive to increases in flood levels. Vertical buffers of 300mm and 600mm have been applied to the Flood Zone 3 flood extent.
Qualitative visual accuracy assessment of the generated flood zones, achieved through comparison with original Flood Map for Planning Flood Zones, is favourable and shows a good level of agreement. This demonstrates that the GIS methodology is robust.
The results of this analysis can be used by the LPAs as a high level screening tool. Where a LPA is considering growth or development adjacent to the floodplain (as defined by the extents of Flood Zone 2, Flood Zone 3, and the outputs of this Fluvial River Floodplain GIS Analysis), detailed hydraulic modelling should be undertaken to assess more accurately the risk of flooding in the future as a result of climate change.
Partnership for South Hampshire Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note: East Solent Model Re-Simulations
Project Number 60653132
Technical Note
- Project number
- 60653132
- Project (Client)
- Partnership for South Hampshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (Portsmouth City Council)
- Subject
- East Solent Flood Inundation Model Re-Simulations (Hayling Island, Portsea Island, Gosport to Warsash)
| Revision | Date | Prepared by | Checked by | Verified by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Version 1 (Draft) | 15 Aug 2022 |
Sophie Brewer (Graduate Consultant) Sarah Littlewood (Principal Consultant) Baoxing Wang (Principal Coastal Modeller) |
Richard Moore (Principal Consultant) | Helen Judd (Associate) |
| Version 2 (Final) | 28 Jun 2023 | Sarah Littlewood (Principal Consultant) | Veronica Makhesh (Senior Consultant) | Helen Judd (Associate) |
| Version 3 (Final) | 26 Jan 2024 | Veronica Makhesh (Senior Consultant) | Sarah Littlewood (Principal Consultant) | Helen Judd (Associate) |
1. Introduction
1.1 Overview
1.1.1 AECOM has been commissioned by Portsmouth City Council (PCC) on behalf of ten planning authorities in South Hampshire (the ‘Partnership for South Hampshire’ (PfSH)) to prepare an updated Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (SFRA). The PfSH SFRA covers the administrative areas of Portsmouth City, Havant Borough, Gosport Borough, Fareham Borough, Eastleigh Borough, Southampton City, Winchester City, Test Valley Borough, New Forest District and New Forest National Park Authority.
1.1.2 The purpose of the SFRA is to assess the risk to an area from flooding from all sources, now and in the future, taking account the impacts of climate change, and to assess the impact that land use changes and development in the area will have on flood risk.
1.1.3 The PfSH SFRA is being prepared in line with the requirements of the National Planning Policy Framework1 (NPPF) and supporting Planning Practice Guidance2 (PPG). Reference has also been made to the Environment Agency guidance ‘How to prepare a strategic flood risk assessment’3.
1.1.4 This guidance advises that one of the elements the SFRA should provide is maps showing the risk of flooding from rivers, the sea, and estuaries, using the Flood Map for Planning and detailed flood modelling. Detailed flood modelling, where available, may be used to show the impact of climate change on flood risk. New or updated flood modelling may be required if flood models are not available, or the climate change allowances in the flood model are not in line with current climate change guidance.
1.1.5 The Environment Agency supplied the existing 2D hydrodynamic tidal models from the East Solent Study4 which was completed in 2015 – 2018. This technical note describes the work undertaken to re-simulate the flood models from the East Solent Study, to provide the required outputs to inform the PfSH SFRA.
1 MHCLG, July 2021, National Planning Policy Framework https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-planning-policy-framework--2
2 DLUHC, MHCLG, August 2022, Planning Practice Guidance https://www.gov.uk/guidance/flood-risk-and-coastal-change
3 Defra, Environment Agency, March 2022. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/local-planning-authorities-strategic-flood-risk-assessment
4 JBA Consulting, July 2018, Model Development Report East Solent Models. JBA Consulting, July 2018, East Solent Flood risk and tidal procedure updates, Final Summary Report.
1.2 Existing East Solent Flood Model
1.2.1 The East Solent Study was undertaken by JBA Consulting between 2015 – 2018. Three separate TUFLOW hydrodynamic tidal models were developed for Hayling Island, Portsea Island and Gosport to Warsash. The model extents are shown in Figure 1-1.
1.2.2 A “With Defences” scenario was simulated for a range of events to understand the present day and future flood risk from tidal sources. A "Without Defences" scenario was also simulated, with all maintained defences removed but defacto defences retaining. This was used to update the Flood Map for Planning Flood Zones and enable the mapping of ‘areas benefitting from defences’ (ABDs) at that time.
1.2.3 For each flood model, the following events were simulated as part of the 2015 study:
- 10%, 4%, 3.33%, 1.33%, 1%, 0.5%, 0.2% and 0.1% Annual Exceedance Probability (AEP) events for the Present Day (2015).
- 0.5% and 0.1% AEP events using UKCP09 climate change guidance medium emissions scenario and projected to the years 2031, 2065 and 2115.
1.2.4 One breach scenario had been considered in the Portsea Island model, at Old Portsmouth.
1.2.5 The following model outputs are available: maximum flood depth, water level, velocity, hazard (ZUK0).
Partnership for South Hampshire Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note: East Solent Model Re-Simulations
Project Number 60653132
2. Model Updates
2.1 LiDAR DTM
2.1.1 The TUFLOW model builds rely on a Digital Terrain Model (DTM) created from light detecting and ranging (LiDAR) data to represent the ground levels across the model domain.
2.1.2 The latest available LiDAR topographic survey data was downloaded at the start of the project from the Data Services Platform5 and included the Environment Agency’s National LiDAR Programme. This was used to update the TUFLOW models for Portsea, and Gosport to Warsash. The 2020 LIDAR Composite contains surveys undertaken between 6th June 2000 and 1st September 2020. Table 2-1 records the datasets that have been used to update the models.
2.1.3 No changes have been made to the bathymetry in the coastal regions as part of this update. It should be noted that for the Portsea model, the ‘portsmouth_harbour’ layer which consists of bathymetry representing the estuary / sea bed around Chichester Harbour, was replaced. This caused model instabilities as ground levels associated with this dataset differed significantly when compared with the new LiDAR data. This is likely due to the time in which the LiDAR was flown i.e. high vs low tide.
Table 2-1 Updates to DTM
| Model | DTM used in 2015 Study | Updated DTM |
|---|---|---|
| Hayling Island |
Filename: dtm Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads an ASCII grid of points attributed with elevations derived from 2m filtered LIDAR data flown in 2013. Previous 2m DTM is sat underneath, flown in 2013, to provide full coverage. |
Filename: Hayling_Island_LiDAR_001 Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads in a text file of points attributed with elevations derived from 1m LIDAR flown in 2020. The following tiles were used: National LiDAR Programme DTM 1m SU60NE (2020), SU70NW (2020), SU70NE (2019), SU70SE (2019), SU70SW (2020), SU60SE (2020), SZ69NE (2020), SZ79NE (2019), SZ79NW (2020) |
| Portsea Island |
Filename: dtm Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads an ASCII grid of points attributed with elevations derived from 2m filtered LIDAR data flown in 2013. Previous 2m DTM is sat underneath, flown in 2013, to provide full coverage. |
Filename: Portsea_Island_LiDAR_001 Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads in a text file of points attributed with elevations derived from 1m LIDAR flown in 2020. The following tiles were used: National LiDAR Programme DTM 1m SU50NE (2020), SU50SE (2020), SU50NW (2020), SU60NE (2020), SU60SE (2020), SZ69NE (2020), SZ69NW (2020), SU60SW (2020) |
| Gosport to Warsash |
Filename: dtm Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads an ASCII grid of points attributed with elevations derived from 2m filtered LIDAR data flown in 2013. Previous 2m DTM is sat underneath, flown in 2013, to provide full coverage. |
Filename: Gosport_LiDAR_001 Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads in a text file of points attributed with elevations derived from 1m LIDAR flown in 2020. The following tiles were used: National LiDAR Programme DTM 1m SU40NE (2020), SU40SE (2020), SU50NW (2020), SU50NE (2020), SU60SW (2020) LiDAR Composite DTM 1m SU50SW (2020), SU50SE (2020), SZ69NW (2020), SZ59NE (2020) |
5 Defra Data Services Platform https://environment.data.gov.uk/
2.2 Flood defences
2.2.1 Flood defence improvement works are underway along North Portsea Island and along the Southsea frontage.
2.2.2 No changes to the flood defence levels were required to the Hayling Island model or the Gosport to Warshaw model. There are proposals for flood defence schemes at Alverstoke and Forton (within the Gosport to Warsash model). These proposals have planning approval and funding but at the time of the preparation of the coastal modelling had not started construction. The decision was taken not to include them until construction is complete.
North Portsea Island Scheme
2.2.3 The preferred coastal defence options around North Portsea Island were decided in 2014 and divided into five phases as shown in Figure 2-1 and described below. Phases 1 – 3 have been completed and are included in the TUFLOW model update:
- Phase 1 - Anchorage Park 2015 - 2016: The construction of 1.4km of earth embankment with rock revetment toe. Design height +4.30m AOD. Construction height varies between +4.50m AOD and +4.60m AOD on the northern frontage to allow for settlement. On the Eastern Road stretch, design height of +4.60m AOD. Constructed between +4.80m AOD and +5.10m AOD on the eastern frontage to allow for settlement.
- Phase 2 - Milton Common 2016: The construction of 1.5km of a setback earth embankment and rock revetment structure. Design height: +4.70m AOD (including 150mm settlement).
- Phase 3 - Tipner Lake 2017 - 2019: The construction of 1.9km of a seawall. Design height: +4.50m AOD.
- Phase 4a & 4b - (a)Eastern Road and (b)Kendall’s Wharf 2019 - 2023: The construction of a seawall with road raising at the entrance to Kendall’s Wharf. Design height: +4.00m AOD design height of the new road. Embankment +4.90m AOD down to +4.60m AOD including settlement allowance. Steel sheet pile wall +4.30m AOD. (Phase 4 has not been included in the TUFLOW model update).
- Phase 5 – Ports Creek 2024 – 2025: Currently going through a detailed design review which once complete will lead to the procurement of the contractor. (Phase 5 has not been included in the TUFLOW model update).
Figure 2-1 North Portsea Island Scheme6
2.2.4 As-built drawings provided by Coastal Partners have been used to update the defence crest levels within the Portsea Island TUFLOW model for those schemes that have been constructed (Phase 1-3). In agreement with project stakeholders it was agreed that the sections of defence that have not yet been constructed should not be included in the model updates until construction is complete (Phase 4 and 5).
Southsea Coastal Scheme
2.2.5 The Southsea Coastal Scheme sets out proposals for building new coastal defences and enable regeneration of the public realm. The design is summarised over the following eight areas:
- Long Curtain Moat: Vertical sea defence with existing high ground and short section of new secondary defence.
- Clarence Pier: grass bund running behind existing buildings. Primary defence could be reintroduced along this line as part of any future development of the area.
- Southsea Common: Existing beach widened combined with a stepped revetment defence and a sloped grass bund. Promenade and road raised.
- Southsea Castle: Rock armour combined with use of existing high ground or new secondary defence. Promenade widened and raised.
- Pyramids Centre: Existing beach widened combined with a stepped revetment defence and buried rock toe.
- South Parade Pier: Stepped revetment defence with a buried rock toe. Steps and rock toe covered in shingle in normal conditions.
- Canoe Lake Park: Existing beach widened combined with a stepped revetment defence and buried rock toe.
- Eastney Esplanade: Long term beach management and monitoring plan put in place to ensure adequate flood risk management. No major flood defence works for approximately next 50 years.
2.2.6 As-built drawings have been provided for Long Curtain Moat and the updated flood defence levels have been incorporated into the TUFLOW model build.
2.2.7 The changes to the flood defence levels for the North Portsea Island Scheme and the Southsea Scheme have been applied using a Z line command in TUFLOW, as described in Table 2-2.
Table 2-2 Flood defence improvements, Portsea Island Model
| Layer Name | Command | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| 2d_zln_DefenceUpgrades2022_002 | Read MI Z Line RIDGE THICK | Data taken from as-built drawings of recent flood defence improvements around North Portsea Island and Southsea. |
2.2.8 No changes to the flood defence levels were required to the Gosport to Warshaw model. There are proposals for flood defence schemes at Alverstoke7 and Forton8 (within the Gosport to Warsash model). These proposals have planning approval and funding but at the time of the preparation of the coastal modelling had not started construction. It was agreed with the project steering group including LPAs, Coastal Partners and the Environment Agency, that these schemes should not be included within the model build until construction is complete.
2.3 Tidal Boundaries
2.3.1 In order to inform the PfSH SFRA, the models needed to be re-simulated to provide an assessment of the risk of flooding both now and into the future, taking account of the new climate change projections on sea level rise. The epochs of interest for the PfSH SFRA are:
- 2022 (present day scenario).
- 2055 (to provide consistency with the epochs in the North Solent Shoreline Management Plan9).
- 2122 (to inform local plan preparation and design life of residential developments (100 years)).
2.3.2 All events include a tidal and wave overtopping boundary.
Existing boundary set up
2.3.3 Two types of boundary data were used as inputs into the flood model, these are:
- a still water boundary, located offshore, which allows propagation of the tide and surge into the model domain, and
- wave overtopping boundaries along the coastal frontage, which inject wave water into the model at the location of flood defences.
2.3.4 As described in the East Solent Model Development Report, the tidal still water boundary requires the generation of design tidal-graphs. These are time-series data that quantifies how sea levels are expected to change through time during an extreme event. It is these design tidal-graphs that are used to drive the still water component of a flood inundation model at its offshore boundaries. The same approach has been applied to generate the design tidal-curves. This requires three components:
- extreme still water sea level estimates taken from the latest coastal extreme guidance for the UK for the return periods of interest,
- a design surge shape taken from the latest coastal extreme guidance for the UK, and
- a design astronomical tide taken from a gauge local to the site.
Climate change allowances
2.3.5 Current guidance on the climate change allowances that should be applied are set out by the Environment Agency10. There are a range of allowances for each river basin district and epoch for sea level rise. The allowances for the south west and south east river basin district are included in Table 2-3. The guidance states that for flood risk assessments and SFRAs, LPAs should assess both the higher central and the upper end allowances.
Table 2-3 Sea level allowances by river basin district for each epoch in mm for each year (based on 1981 to 2000 baseline) – the total sea level rise for each epoch is in brackets
| Area of England | Allowance | 2000 to 2035 (mm) | 2036 to 2065 (mm) | 2066 to 2095 (mm) | 2096 to 2125 (mm) | Cumulative rise 2000 to 2125 (metres) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| South east | Higher central | 5.7 (200) | 8.7 (261) | 11.6 (348) | 13.1 (393) | 1.20 |
| South east | Upper end | 6.9 (242) | 11.3 (339) | 15.8 (474) | 18.2 (546) | 1.60 |
| South west | Higher central | 5.8 (203) | 8.8 (264) | 11.7 (351) | 13.1 (393) | 1.21 |
| South west | Upper end | 7 (245) | 11.4 (342) | 16 (480) | 18.4 (552) | 1.62 |
2.3.6 The guidance states, to calculate sea level using Table 2-3, add the allowances for the appropriate one of the 6 geographical areas:
- up to 2035, use the mm for each year rates for the appropriate geographical area, starting from the present day extreme sea levels from Coastal design sea levels – coastal flood boundary extreme sea levels (2018)11.
- from 2036 to 2065, get the increase in sea level by adding the number of years on from 2035 (to 2065), multiplied by the respective rate for the appropriate geographical area – if the whole time period applies use the cumulative total.
- treat time periods 2066 to 2095 and 2096 to 2125 as you would 2036 to 2065.
2.3.7 Where it is appropriate to apply a credible maximum scenario, use the H++ allowance. There is no H++ value for sea level rise beyond 2100. For the change to relative mean sea level use the H++ scenario of 1.9m for the total sea level rise to 2100.
Updated boundaries
2.3.8 AECOM obtained the latest Coastal Flood Boundary (CFB) dataset (2018) and calculated the revised extreme still water levels using UKCP18 climate change projections for RCP 8.5 at 70th (higher central) and 95th percentiles (upper end) for the 0.5% AEP event for the years 2022, 2055 and 2122. The H++ water level was also generated for the year 2122.
2.3.9 To generate the extreme tidal curve, the same approach was applied as that implemented in the JBA 2015 study. The surge profile at Portsmouth was used for all sites and the astronomical tides were generated using harmonic constants given in Admiralty Tide Tables. The same period tides (13/10/2012 and 19/10/2012) have been used as presented in 2015 JBA report. An example of the resulting tidal graph for chainage point ‘4616’ at Portsmouth Harbour mouth is shown in Figure 2-2. Each of the 2D hydrodynamic models were run for four tidal cycles, to capture the highest peak tidal levels, with the simulation time starting at 52.25 hours and ending at 101.75 hours.
Figure 2-2 Design tidal graph for 0.5% AEP event (2022) based on CFB chainage points 4616 at Portsmouth Harbour mouth
2.3.10 When the East Solent models were simulated in the most recent version of TUFLOW, there was an issue with the mass error which is a sign of poor numerical convergence which could impact the accuracy of the model outputs. This error was associated with the HX line (which links the 1D and 2D elements of the hydraulic model) which interpolates the tidal levels along the tidal boundary.
2.3.11 Following discussions with TUFLOW support, it was agreed that the HX line should be removed from the model and replaced with a HT boundary. This boundary specifies a water level versus a time hydrograph at a particular location. To apply this boundary, several HT boundaries were used to interpolate tidal levels along the boundary of the model. It should be noted that this method is more conservative that the HX approach, as the level of interpolation using this approach is less detailed and it is therefore likely that a slightly higher water level will be applied in some areas.
Wave overtopping
It was agreed with the project steering group that no changes would be made to the wave overtopping boundaries as part of the model re-simulations. Instead, a comparison of the newly calculated maximum water levels for the years 2022, 2055 and 2122 was undertaken with the water levels modelled in the 2015 study, and the wave overtopping inputs for the AEP events that were closest to these events were applied for each event. This is demonstrated in Table 2-4.
It should be noted that for 0.5% AEP (2055) upper end, the wave overtopping inputs corresponding to the water levels modelled in the 2015 study (i.e 0.1% AEP (2031) using UKC09) were not available. So, the next available equivalent - 0.5% AEP 2065 using UKCP09 was substituted. However, a select few of these overtopping inputs (mainly along the Mengham beach front) were lower than the values applied for the higher central estimates (0.5% AEP (2055) higher central). Therefore, the values were compared and the higher of the two were applied to provide a conservative assessment.
Table 2-4 Wave Overtopping Inputs
| Required Event for PfSH SFRA | Wave overtopping inputs applied from 2015 study |
|---|---|
| 3.3% AEP (2022) | 3.3% AEP (2015) |
| 3.3% AEP (2122) higher central | 0.1% AEP (2015) |
| 0.5% AEP (2022) | 0.5% AEP (2015) |
| 0.5% AEP (2055) higher central | 0.1% AEP (2015) |
| 0.5% AEP (2122) higher central | 0.1% AEP 2115 using UKCP09 |
| 0.5% AEP (2055) upper end | 0.1% AEP (2015) and 0.5% AEP 2065 using UKCP09 |
| 0.5% AEP (2122) upper end | 0.1% AEP 2115 using UKCP09 |
| 0.1% AEP (2055) upper end | 0.1% AEP 2065 using UKCP09 |
| 0.1% AEP (2122) upper end | 0.1% AEP 2115 using UKCP09 |
2.3.12 The overtopping discharge was applied in the 2D hydrodynamic models at the same time as the peak tidal cycle.
Other Model Updates
2.3.13 Other minor updates to the East Solent models include:
- For the Portsea model two stability patches included within the received model were refined. The first (2d_ztin_Portsmouth_stability_004a) was updated to smooth out the bathymetry and the second (2d_zrg_stability_003) was updated to improve the representation at the HM Naval Base Harbour.
- The Initial Water Levels (IWLs) were updated within all models to reflect the changes to the tidal boundary.
2.4 Modelled Scenarios
2.4.1 The scenarios simulated as part of this study alongside the peak extreme still water level are presented in Table 2-5. It should be highlighted that for each model the peak extreme water level has been extracted from the main coastal boundary. Depending on coastal location, the extreme still water level changes. For example, in estuary areas the water level will be different and therefore a factor is applied in the model to account for this. The 0.5% AEP event for 2122 H++ climate change allowance was only simulated for the Gosport to Warsash model as requested by Gosport BC.
Table 2-5 Modelled Scenarios
| AEP | Epoch | Climate Change | Gosport Peak Extreme Still Water Level (m AOD) | Hayling Peak Extreme Still Water Level (m AOD) | Portsea Peak Extreme Still Water Level (m AOD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Defended | |||||
| 3.3% | 2022 | Present Day (70th) | 2.94 | 3.23 | 2.97 |
| 3.3% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.98 | 4.27 | 4.01 |
| 0.5% | 2022 | Present Day (70th) | 3.13 | 3.26 | 3.20 |
| 0.5% | 2055 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.37 | 3.50 | 3.44 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 4.17 | 4.30 | 4.24 |
| 0.5% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.44 | 3.57 | 3.51 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.54 | 4.67 | 4.61 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | H++ | 5.12 | n/a | n/a |
| 0.1% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.59 | 3.74 | 3.67 |
| 0.1% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.69 | 4.84 | 4.77 |
| Undefended | |||||
| 0.5% | 2055 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.37 | 3.50 | 3.44 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 4.17 | 4.30 | 4.24 |
| 0.1% | 2055 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.52 | 3.67 | 3.60 |
| 0.1% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 4.32 | 4.47 | 4.40 |
| 0.5% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.44 | 3.57 | 3.51 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.54 | 4.67 | 4.61 |
| 0.1% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.59 | 3.74 | 3.67 |
| 0.1% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.69 | 4.84 | 4.77 |
2.5 Outputs
2.5.1 The following outputs have been supplied to the client group for each modelled scenario.
- Maximum depth grid (ASCII format).
- Maximum hazard (ZUK0) grid (ASCII format).
- Maximum water level grid (ASCII format).
- Maximum flood extent grid (GIS shapefile).
2.6 Future Flood Zones
2.6.1 In order to provide an indication of how the Flood Zones may change in the future as a result of climate change, a future Flood Zone 2 and future Flood Zone 3 have been generated. The same approach has been applied as was used for generating the Flood Zones in the 2015 East Solent Study:
- Future Flood Zone 2 was generated by combining the maximum flood extents for the 0.1% AEP (Upper End) 2122 defended and undefended scenarios.
- Future Flood Zone 3 was generated by combining the maximum flood extents for the 0.5% AEP (Upper End) 2122 defended and undefended scenarios.
2.6.2 Flood Zones 2 and 3, as shown on the Flood Map for Planning (Rivers and Sea), are generally described as presenting the risk of flooding from the sea assuming defences are not in place. However, it is noted that, somewhat counterintuitively, in some locations the maximum flood extent is greater during the defended model simulation compared to the undefended simulation. The removal of raised flood defences from the model enables water to flow back out to sea as the tide recedes, whereas during the defended scenarios it remains in the model domain and accumulates with the next tidal cycle.
2.6.3 Furthermore, in some locations the ground levels are above the still water flood risk and the flood risk comes only from wave overtopping. In these situations, the modelling approach can lead to the defended flood risk areas being larger than the undefended flood risk extents. This is due to the wave overtopping ponding behind the defences in the defended scenarios but flowing back to sea in the undefended scenarios.
2.6.4 As a result, the future Flood Zones presented in this SFRA are derived from the maximum flood extent from both the undefended and defended scenarios, rather that solely the undefended scenario. As noted above, this is consistent with the method applied in the 2015 East Solent Study.
6 Coastal Partners Website: https://coastalpartners.org.uk/project/protecting-the-future-of-north-portsea-island/
7 Description of Alverstoke Coastal Defence Scheme, Coastal Partners Webpage https://coastalpartners.org.uk/project/alverstoke-coastal-defence-scheme-152
8 Description of Forton Scheme, Coastal Partners Webpage https://coastalpartners.org.uk/project/forton-scheme
9 North Solent Shoreline Management Plan https://www.northsolentsmp.co.uk/
10 Environment Agency, May 2022, Flood risk assessments: climate change allowances https://www.gov.uk/guidance/flood-risk-assessments-climate-change-allowances
11 Coastal Design Sea Levels - Coastal Flood Boundary Extreme Sea Levels (2018) https://data.gov.uk/dataset/73834283-7dc4-488a-9583-a920072d9a9d/coastal-design-sea-levels-coastal-flood-boundary-extreme-sea-levels-2018
Partnership for South Hampshire Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note: East Solent Model Re-Simulations
Project Number 60653132
3. Breach modelling
3.1 Residual risk
3.1.1 The Planning Practice Guidance2 (PPG), defines residual risks as those remaining after applying the sequential approach to the location of development and taking mitigating actions. Examples of residual flood risk include:
- the failure of flood management infrastructure such as a breach of a raised flood defence, blockage of a surface water conveyance system, overtopping of an upstream storage area, or failure of a pumped drainage system
- failure of a reservoir, or
- a severe flood event that exceeds a flood management design standard, such as a flood that overtops a raised flood defence, or an intense rainfall event which the drainage system cannot cope with.
3.1.2 Areas behind flood defences are at particular risk from rapid onset of fast-flowing and deep water flooding, with little or no warning if defences are overtopped or breached.
3.1.3 The SFRA should consider the residual risk of flooding in the study area.
3.1.4 The coastal modelling described in Section 2 includes ‘undefended’ scenarios, which enable an assessment of the risks if defences were not in place. However, as described in the Environment Agency Breach of Defences Guidance12, the development of ‘with defences’ and ‘without defences’ modelling and mapping is not a surrogate for residual risk assessment and can both overestimate and in some cases underestimate the ‘true’ flood risk and hazard. In addition, the hazard from a sudden release of water from a failure is often not properly appreciated in assessments of flood defences.
3.1.5 There is scope within the SFRA to carry out breach assessments at specific locations around the study area, where appropriate. The justification for these specific breach assessments as part of the SFRA will depend on where development is proposed, and the local characteristics of the defences that could make them susceptible to a breach, for example:
- Whether it is a ‘breachable’ location, i.e. the ground levels behind the defence are lower than the crest level of the defence
- Whether there are any vulnerable points in the existing defence, for example structures in the defence or a known defect.
3.2 Breach locations and parameters
3.2.1 Breach locations have been identified based on a review of the defence types, the extent of Flood Zone 2 and a review of the ground levels behind the defence using LiDAR topographic data. The breach locations were discussed and agreed with the Environment Agency and steering group in Summer 2021.
3.2.2 The Environment Agency Breach of Defences Guidance12 sets out the parameters that should be applied for different types of defence. Table 3-1 reproduced from the guidance summarises the breach widths and time to close.
3.2.3 The invert level of the breach has been determined by interrogation of the LiDAR on the landward side of the breach location, applying the rule of thumb that the breach invert level should be the lowest ground level within a radius the same as the breach width.
3.2.4 The breaches are modelled to occur 1 hour prior to the peak water level and lower the defence to the specific invert level over a set period of time, dependent on the type of defence. The length of defence defined to breach is lowered using a variable zshape feature in TUFLOW.
12 Environment Agency, 29th June 2021, LIT56413 Breach of Defences Guidance.
Table 3-1 Breach parameters (width and time to close)
| Source | Defence Type | Breach Width (m) | Time to close – urban (hrs) | Time to close – rural (hrs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Estuary/Tidal River | Earth Bank | 50 | 30 | 30 |
| Reinforced Concrete | 20 | 18 | 18 | |
| Open Coast | Earth Bank | 200 | 44 | 56 |
| Earth Bank with facing | 100 | 44 | 56 | |
| Dunes | 100 | 44 | 56 | |
| Shingle Bank | 100 | 30 | 30 | |
| Reinforced Concrete | 50 | 18 | 30 | |
| River | Earth Bank | 40 | 30 | 56 |
| Reinforced Concrete | 20 | 18 | 18 | |
| Tidal/Coastal | Tidal Gates | Gate width | Gates fail on low tide preceding the peak level with emergency closure effected during the following low tide | |
3.2.5 The following section demonstrates the location of each breach and provides a table presenting the key information such as defence type, source of flood risk, width of the breach, invert levels both seaward and landward and also the length of time the defence is breached. The specific breach reference is also provided which relates directly to the model simulations.
3.2.6 Given the model simulation time (approximately 3 days), breach locations were grouped together based on location and length of time the defences are breached. It was ensured that breach locations that were modelled within the same simulation were located suitably far apart to ensure that the flood extents did not converge. Where required, flood defences within the rest of the model were raised to 100m AOD to ensure that floodwater entering the model domain was from the breach only and not from overtopping of other defences. This is based on the information within the SMP9. Where defences are to be maintained or improved, these were raised within the model. The overtopping boundaries were also removed from the model.
3.2.7 For Hayling Island, a total of 3 breach models were simulated. One included breach locations STO1, EAS2 and MAR1, another included NOR1, EAS1 and EAS3 and the final model included MEN1.
3.2.8 For Portsea Island, a total of 3 breach models (A, B and C) were simulated. Breach A included breach locations POR1, HOR1, ESN_OPTION_2 and HIL1, Breach B included breach location ESN_OPTION_1 and Breach C included breach location Old_Portsmouth_AEC.
3.2.9 For the Gosport to Warsash model, a total of 2 breach model was simulated. One included breach locations HAS1 and BLO2 while the other included breach locations BLO1 and WAR2.
3.2.10 Each breach model was simulated for the 0.5% AEP event for 2122 using the upper end (95th percentile) climate change allowance on sea level rise.
3.3 Hayling Island Model – Breaches
Breach Location NOR1
Location of breach NOR1
| Breach Reference | NOR1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SU7327503956 |
| Description of location | Shoreline north of Northney village (North Hayling). |
| Description of defence | Earth Bank |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 50 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 1.1 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 3.7 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 30 |
Breach Location STO1
Location of breach STO1
| Breach Reference | STO1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SU7171402944 |
| Description of location | Stoke (eastern shore of Langstone Harbour). |
| Description of defence | Shingle bank |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 50 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.6 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 2.2 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 30 |
Breach Location MEN1
Location of breach MEN1
| Breach Reference | MEN1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ7383199257 |
| Description of location | Mengham Salterns (western side of Chichester Harbour). |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 20 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 1.2 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 2.0 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location MAR1
Location of breach MAR1
| Breach Reference | MAR1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ7453898857 |
| Description of location | Marina, Hayling Island |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 20 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.9 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 2.7 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location EAS3
Location of breach EAS3
| Breach Reference | EAS3 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ7453898857 |
| Description of location | Eastern end of Eastoke beach near Southwood Road (Hayling Island). |
| Description of defence | Shingle Bank |
| Source | Open Coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 100 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.5 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 4.0 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 30 |
Breach Location EAS2
Location of breach EAS2
| Breach Reference | EAS2 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ7314798368 |
| Description of location | Eastoke beach near Bembridge Drive. |
| Description of defence | Shingle Bank |
| Source | Open Coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 100 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.2 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 4.5 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 30 |
Breach Location EAS1
Location of breach EAS1
| Breach Reference | EAS1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ7244998588 |
| Description of location | Eastoke beach near Bound Lane (Hayling Island). |
| Description of defence | Shingle Bank |
| Source | Open Coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 100 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 1.3 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 4.6 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 30 |
3.4 Portsea Island Model – Breaches
Breach Location HIL1
Location of breach HIL1
| Breach Reference | HIL1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SU6497504157 |
| Description of location | East side of Hilsea Bastion Gardens (immediately opposite M275). |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 20 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.8 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 1.9 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location POR1
Location of breach POR1
| Breach Reference | POR1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SU6241504942 |
| Description of location | West side of Paulsgrove Lake (Portchester). |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 20 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 1.3 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 1.4 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location HOR1
Location of breach HOR1
| Breach Reference | HOR1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SU6378603975 |
| Description of location | Southern side of Horsea Island. |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 20 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.2 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 2.6 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location ESN OPTION 1
Location of breach ESN OPTION 1
| Breach Reference | ESN OPTION 1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ6763498913 |
| Description of location | Eastern end of Eastney Beach. |
| Description of defence | Shingle Bank |
| Source | Open coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 100 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 4.4 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 3.9 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 30 |
Breach Location ESN OPTION 2
Location of breach ESN OPTION 2
| Breach Reference | ESN OPTION 2 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ6614098387 |
| Description of location | Western end of Eastney Beach. |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Open coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 50 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 4.4 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 4.3 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location OLD PORTSMOUTH AEC 001
Location of breach OLD PORTSMOUTH AEC 001
| Breach Reference | OLD PORTSMOUTH AEC 001 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ6310199219 |
| Description of location | Western side of Old Portsmouth |
| Description of defence | Reinforced Concrete Wall |
| Source | Open coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 50 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.3 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 3.0 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
3.5 Gosport to Warsash Inundation Model
Breach Location BLO2
Location of breach BLO2
| Breach Reference | BLO2 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ6257699165 |
| Description of location | Fort Blockhouse, Gosport |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Open coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 50 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.4 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 4.5 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location BLO1
Location of breach BLO1
| Breach Reference | BLO1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ6224298874 |
| Description of location | South of Fort Blockhouse, Gosport. |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Open Coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 50 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.4 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 5.4 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location HAS1
Location of breach HAS1
| Breach Reference | HAS1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SZ6159898264 |
| Description of location | Haslar sea wall (south of Dolphin Way). |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Open Coast |
| Width of breach (m) | 50 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.4 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 5.1 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location WAR2
Location of breach WAR2
| Breach Reference | WAR2 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SU4896205328 |
| Description of location | Warsash maritime academy |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 20 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.2 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 0.8 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Partnership for South Hampshire Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note: Southampton Water Model Re-Simulation
Project Number 60653132
Technical Note
- Project number
- 60653132
- Project (Client)
- Partnership for South Hampshire Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (Portsmouth City Council)
- Subject
- Southampton Water Model Re-Simulation
| Revision | Date | Prepared by | Checked by | Verified by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Version 1 (Draft) | 15 Aug 2022 |
Sophie Brewer (Graduate Consultant) Sarah Littlewood (Principal Consultant) Baoxing Wang (Principal Coastal Modeller) |
Richard Moore (Principal Consultant) | Helen Judd (Associate) |
| Version 2 (Final) | 28 Jun 2023 | Sarah Littlewood (Principal Consultant) | Veronica Makhesh (Senior Consultant) | Helen Judd (Associate) |
1. Introduction
1.1 Overview
1.1.1 AECOM has been commissioned by Portsmouth City Council (PCC), on behalf of ten planning authorities in South Hampshire (the ‘Partnership for South Hampshire’ (PfSH)) to prepare an updated Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (SFRA). The PfSH SFRA covers the administrative areas of Portsmouth City, Havant Borough, Gosport Borough, Fareham Borough, Eastleigh Borough, Southampton City, Winchester City, Test Valley Borough, New Forest District and New Forest National Park Authority.
1.1.2 The purpose of the SFRA is to assess the risk to an area from flooding from all sources, now and in the future, taking account the impacts of climate change, and to assess the impact that land use changes and development in the area will have on flood risk.
1.1.3 The PfSH SFRA is being prepared in line with the requirements of the National Planning Policy Framework1 (NPPF) and supporting Planning Practice Guidance2 (PPG). Reference has also been made to the Environment Agency guidance ‘How to prepare a strategic flood risk assessment’3.
1.1.4 This guidance advises that one of the elements the SFRA should provide is maps showing the risk of flooding from rivers, the sea, and estuaries, using the Flood Map for Planning and detailed flood modelling. Detailed flood modelling, where available, may be used to show the impact of climate change on flood risk. New or updated flood modelling may be required if flood models are not available, or the climate change allowances in the model are not in line with current climate change guidance.
1.1.5 The Environment Agency supplied the existing 2D hydrodynamic model from the Southampton Water Coastal Modelling Study4 to inform the PfSH SFRA. This technical note describes the work undertaken to re-simulate the flood model from the Southampton Water Coastal Modelling Study, to provide the required outputs to inform the PfSH SFRA.
1.2 Existing Southampton Water Model
1.2.1 The Southampton Water Coastal Modelling Study was completed by JBA Consulting in 2014 using TUFLOW software. It was commissioned by the Environment Agency to produce a single Southampton Water model to improve understanding and confidence in the prediction of exposure to coastal flood risk within the Solent Estuary.
1.2.2 The “With Defences” scenario was simulated for a range of events to understand the present day and future flood risk from tidal sources. The "Without Defences" scenario was also required to update the current Environment Agency's Flood Zones and enable the mapping of areas benefitting from defences (ABDs) at that time.
1.2.3 The area modelled includes Southampton Water, the tidal regions of the River Hamble, River Itchen and River Test. The downstream extent of the model is the mouth of Southampton Water, extending from the high ground at Calshot in the west to high ground south of Warsash in the east. The model extent is shown in Figure 1-1.
1.2.4 The following model simulations were completed as part of the 2014 project:
- With defences 0.5% and 0.1% for 2075 and 2115 (UKCP09)
- Without defences 0.5% and 0.1% for 2115 (using both Defra 2006 and UKCP09 estimates)
1.2.5 The following model outputs are available: maximum flood depth, water level, velocity, hazard (ZUK0).
1 MHCLG, July 2021, National Planning Policy Framework https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/national-planning-policy-framework--2
2 DLUHC, MHCLG, August 2022, Planning Practice Guidance https://www.gov.uk/guidance/flood-risk-and-coastal-change
3 Defra, Environment Agency, March 2022 https://www.gov.uk/guidance/local-planning-authorities-strategic-flood-risk-assessment
4 JBA Consulting, 2014, Southampton Water Coastal Modelling Study.
Partnership for South Hampshire Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note: Southampton Water Model Re-Simulation
Project Number 60653132
2. Model Updates
2.1 LiDAR DTM
2.1.1 The TUFLOW model build relies on a Digital Terrain Model (DTM) created from light detecting and ranging (LiDAR) data to represent the ground levels across the model domain.
2.1.2 The latest available LiDAR topographic survey data has been downloaded from the Data Services Platform5 and included the Environment Agency’s National LiDAR Programme. This was used to update the Southampton Water TUFLOW model. The 2020 LiDAR Composite contains surveys undertaken between 6th June 2000 and 1st September 2020.
2.1.3 Table 2-1 records the datasets that have been used to update the model. It should be noted that the ‘Soton_LiDAR_001’ dataset represents mainland while the ‘DTM_1m_SouthamptonArea2’ represents the Solent Estuary and associated watercourses. This layer helped with model stability as the representation of this area was more consistent and accurate.
2.1.4 With new LiDAR data available, the bathymetry data that represented the estuary / sea bed in the existing model was replaced. This caused model instabilities as ground levels associated with this dataset differed significantly when compared with the LiDAR data. This is likely due to the time in which the LiDAR was flown i.e. high vs low tide.
Table 2-1 Updates to DTM
| Model | DTM used in 2015 Study | Updated DTM |
|---|---|---|
| Southampton Water |
Filename: lidar2m, lidar1m Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads an ASCII grid of points attributed with elevations derived from 1m filtered LIDAR data flown between 2007 and 2011. Previous 2m DTM is sat underneath to provide full coverage. |
Filename: Soton_LiDAR_001, DTM_1m_SouthamptonArea2_trim Command: Read GRID Zpts TUFLOW reads in a text file of points attributed with elevations derived from 1m LIDAR flown in 2020. The following tiles were used: National LiDAR Programme DTM 1m SU31NW (2020), SU31NE (2020), SU31SW (2020), SU31SE (2020), SU30NE (2020), SU40NW (2020), SU40SW (2020), SU40SE (2020), SU40NE (2020), SU41SE (2020), SU41SW (2020), SU41NW (2020), SU41NE (2020), SU51SW (2020), SU50NW (2020) LiDAR Composite DTM 1m SU50SW (2020) |
2.2 Tidal boundaries
2.2.1 In order to inform the PfSH SFRA, the Southampton Water model needed to be re-simulated to provide an assessment of the risk of flooding both now and into the future, taking account of the new climate change projections on sea level rise. The epochs of interest for the PfSH SFRA are:
- 2022 (present day scenario).
- 2055 (to provide consistency with the North Solent Shoreline Management Plan6).
- 2122 (to inform local plan preparation and design life of residential developments (100 years)).
Existing boundary set-up
2.2.2 Two types of boundary data were used as inputs into the model, these are:
- a still water boundary, located at the mouth of Southampton Water, which allows propagation of the tide and surge into the model domain from the Solent; and,
- wind boundary data applied across the entire model domain, which applies wind stresses to the water surface and creates a wind setup upstream in the study estuaries.
2.2.3 Derivation of the extreme tidal curves for the still water level boundary requires three components:
- extreme still water sea level estimates taken from the latest coastal extreme guidance for the UK for the return periods of interest,
- a design surge shape taken from the latest coastal extreme guidance for the UK, and
- a design astronomical tide taken from a gauge local to the site.
Climate change allowances
2.2.4 Current guidance on the climate change allowances that should be applied are set out by the Environment Agency7. There are a range of allowances for each river basin district and epoch for sea level rise. The allowances for the south-west and south east river basin district are included in Table 2-2. The guidance states that for flood risk assessments and SFRAs, LPAs should assess both the higher central and the upper end allowances.
Table 2-2 Sea level allowances by river basin district for each epoch in mm for each year (based on 1981 to 2000 baseline) – the total sea level rise for each epoch is in brackets
| Area of England | Allowance | 2000 to 2035 (mm) | 2036 to 2065 (mm) | 2066 to 2095 (mm) | 2096 to 2125 (mm) | Cumulative rise 2000 to 2125 (metres) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| South east | Higher central | 5.7 (200) | 8.7 (261) | 11.6 (348) | 13.1 (393) | 1.20 |
| South east | Upper end | 6.9 (242) | 11.3 (339) | 15.8 (474) | 18.2 (546) | 1.60 |
| South west | Higher central | 5.8 (203) | 8.8 (264) | 11.7 (351) | 13.1 (393) | 1.21 |
| South west | Upper end | 7 (245) | 11.4 (342) | 16 (480) | 18.4 (552) | 1.62 |
2.2.5 The guidance states, to calculate sea level using Table 2-2, add the allowances for the appropriate one of the 6 geographical areas:
- up to 2035, use the mm for each year rates for the appropriate geographical area, starting from the present day extreme sea levels from Coastal design sea levels – coastal flood boundary extreme sea levels (2018)8.
- from 2036 to 2065, get the increase in sea level by adding the number of years on from 2035 (to 2065), multiplied by the respective rate shown in table 2 for the appropriate geographical area – if the whole time period applies use the cumulative total.
- treat time periods 2066 to 2095 and 2096 to 2125 as you would 2036 to 2065.
Where it is appropriate to apply a credible maximum scenario, use the H++ allowance. There is no H++ value for sea level rise beyond 2100. For the change to relative mean sea level use the H++ scenario of 1.9m for the total sea level rise to 2100.
Updated boundaries
2.2.6 AECOM obtained the latest Coastal Flood Boundary (CFB) dataset (2018) and calculated the revised extreme still water levels using UKCP18 climate change projections for RCP 8.5 at 70th (higher central) and 95th percentiles (upper end) for the 0.5% AEP event for the years 2022, 2055 and 2122.
2.2.7 To generate the extreme tidal curve, the same approach was applied as that implemented in the JBA 2014 study. The surge profile at Portsmouth was used and the astronomical tides were generated using harmonic constants given in Admiralty Tide Tables. The same period tides (13/10/2012 and 19/10/2012) have been used as presented in 2014 JBA report. An example of the resulting extreme tidal curve for chainage point ‘4631’ at Calshot Castle at the mouth of Southampton Water is shown in Figure 2-1.
Figure 2-1 Design tidal graph for 0.5% AEP event (2022) based on CFB chainage points 4632 at Calshot Castle
Other Model Updates
2.2.8 Other minor updates to the Southampton Water model include:
- Simulation time changed in the event file (.trf) to 52.25 hours start and 101.75 hours end. This was consistent with the simulations undertaken as part of the East Solent modelling and now includes three tidal cycles including the peak of the event (73.50 hours).
- A number of patches were introduced into the model to smooth ground levels where LiDAR had not been filtered correctly (2d_zsh_SOTON_005_lidar_corr).
- The Initial Water Levels (IWLs) were updated to reflect the changes to the tidal boundary.
- With new LiDAR data being used, improvements were made around the inlet to Bartley Water. This involved modifying the layers ‘2d_zsh_SOTON_Bartley_Water_001’ and ‘2d_zsh_SOTON_002’ to include updated ground levels using the latest LiDAR dataset.
2.3 Modelled Scenarios
2.3.1 The scenarios simulated as part of this study alongside the peak extreme still water level are presented in Table 2-3.
Table 2-3 Modelled Scenarios
| AEP | Epoch | Climate Change | Peak Extreme Still Water Level (m AOD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Defended | |||
| 3.3% | 2022 | Present Day (70th) | 2.68 |
| 3.3% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.72 |
| 0.5% | 2022 | Present Day (70th) | 2.87 |
| 0.5% | 2055 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.11 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.91 |
| 0.5% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.18 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.28 |
| 0.1% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.31 |
| 0.1% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.41 |
| Undefended | |||
| 0.5% | 2055 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.11 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.91 |
| 0.1% | 2055 | Higher Central (70th) | 3.24 |
| 0.1% | 2122 | Higher Central (70th) | 4.04 |
| 0.5% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.18 |
| 0.5% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.28 |
| 0.1% | 2055 | Upper End (95th) | 3.31 |
| 0.1% | 2122 | Upper End (95th) | 4.41 |
2.3.2 The undefended model scenario provides an indication of the extent of the Flood Map for Planning Flood Zone 3 for the present day and in the future (2122) which is useful for applying the sequential test during local plan preparation.
2.4 Outputs
2.4.1 The following outputs have been supplied to the client group for each modelled scenario:
- Maximum depth grid (ASCII format).
- Maximum hazard (ZUK0) grid (ASCII format).
- Maximum water level grid (ASCII format).
- Maximum flood extent grid (GIS shapefile).
2.5 Future Flood Zones
2.5.1 In order to provide an indication of how the Flood Zones may change in the future as a result of climate change, a future Flood Zone 2 and future Flood Zone 3 have been generated:
- Future Flood Zone 2 was generated from the maximum flood extents for the 0.1% AEP (Upper End) 2122 undefended scenario.
- Future Flood Zone 3 was generated from the maximum flood extents for the 0.5% AEP (Upper End) 2122 undefended scenario.
5 Defra Data Services Platform https://environment.data.gov.uk/
6 North Solent Shoreline Management Plan https://www.northsolentsmp.co.uk/
7 Environment Agency, May 2022, Flood risk assessments: climate change allowances https://www.gov.uk/guidance/flood-risk-assessments-climate-change-allowances
8 Coastal Design Sea Levels - Coastal Flood Boundary Extreme Sea Levels (2018) https://data.gov.uk/dataset/73834283-7dc4-488a-9583-a920072d9a9d/coastal-design-sea-levels-coastal-flood-boundary-extreme-sea-levels-2018
Partnership for South Hampshire Level 1 Strategic Flood Risk Assessment
PART 1 Main Report Appendix A: Technical Note: Southampton Water Model Re-Simulation
Project Number 60653132
3. Breach modelling
3.1 Residual risk
3.1.1 The Planning Practice Guidance2 (PPG), defines residual risks as those remaining after applying the sequential approach to the location of development and taking mitigating actions. Examples of residual flood risk include:
- the failure of flood management infrastructure such as a breach of a raised flood defence, blockage of a surface water conveyance system, overtopping of an upstream storage area, or failure of a pumped drainage system;
- failure of a reservoir, or,
- a severe flood event that exceeds a flood management design standard, such as a flood that overtops a raised flood defence, or an intense rainfall event which the drainage system cannot cope with.
3.1.2 Areas behind flood defences are at particular risk from rapid onset of fast-flowing and deep-water flooding, with little or no warning if defences are overtopped or breached.
3.1.3 The SFRA should consider the residual risk of flooding in the study area.
3.1.4 The coastal modelling described in Section 2 includes ‘undefended’ scenarios, which enable an assessment of the risks if defences were not in place. However, as described in the Environment Agency Breach of Defences Guidance9, the development of ‘with defences’ and ‘without defences’ modelling and mapping is not a surrogate for residual risk assessment and can both overestimate and in some cases underestimate the ‘true’ flood risk and hazard. In addition, the hazard from a sudden release of water from a failure is often not properly appreciated in assessments of flood defences.
3.1.5 There is scope within the SFRA to carry out breach assessments at specific locations around the study area, where appropriate. The justification for these specific breach assessments as part of the SFRA will depend on where development is proposed, and the local characteristics of the defences that could make them susceptible to a breach, for example:
- Whether it is a ‘breachable’ location, i.e. the ground levels behind the defence are lower than the crest level of the defence.
- Whether there are any vulnerable points in the existing defence, for example structures in the defence or a known defect.
3.2 Breach locations and parameters
3.2.1 Breach locations have been identified based on a review of the defence types, the extent of Flood Zone 2 and a review of the ground levels behind the defence using LiDAR topographic data. The breach locations were discussed and agreed with the Environment Agency and steering group in Summer 2021.
3.2.2 The Environment Agency Breach of Defences Guidance9 sets out the parameters that should be applied for different types of defence. Table 3-1, reproduced from the guidance summarises the breach widths and time to close.
3.2.3 The invert level of the breach has been determined by interrogation of the LiDAR on the landward side of the breach location, applying the rule of thumb that the breach invert level should be the lowest ground level within a radius the same as the breach width.
9 Environment Agency, 29th June 2021, LIT56413 Breach of Defences Guidance.
Table 3-1 Breach parameters (width and time to close)
| Source | Defence Type | Breach Width (m) | Time to close – urban (hrs) | Time to close – rural (hrs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Estuary/Tidal River | Earth Bank | 50 | 30 | 30 |
| Reinforced Concrete | 20 | 18 | 18 | |
| Open Coast | Earth Bank | 200 | 44 | 56 |
| Earth Bank with facing | 100 | 44 | 56 | |
| Dunes | 100 | 44 | 56 | |
| Shingle Bank | 100 | 30 | 30 | |
| Reinforced Concrete | 50 | 18 | 30 | |
| River | Earth Bank | 40 | 30 | 56 |
| Reinforced Concrete | 20 | 18 | 18 | |
| Tidal/Coastal | Tidal Gates | Gate width | Gates fail on low tide preceding the peak level with emergency closure effected during the following low tide | |
3.2.4 The breaches are modelled to occur 1 hour prior to the peak water level and lower the defence to the specific invert level over a set period of time, dependent on the type of defence. The length of defence defined to breach is lowered using a variable zshape feature in TUFLOW.
3.2.5 The following section demonstrates the location of each breach and provides a table presenting the key information such as defence type, source of flood risk, width of the breach, invert levels both seaward and landward and also the length of time the defence is breached. The specific breach reference is also provided which relates directly to the model simulations.
3.2.6 Given the model simulation time (approximately 3 days), breach locations were grouped together based on location and length of time the defences are breached. It was ensured that breach locations that were modelled within the same simulation were located suitably far apart to ensure that the flood extents did not converge.
3.2.7 For Southampton Water a total of 2 breach models were simulated. One included breach locations MAC1, HYT1 and HAM1 while the other included breach locations ELI1 and ITC1.
3.2.8 Each breach model was simulated for the 0.5% AEP event for 2122 using the upper end (95th percentile) climate change allowance on sea level rise.
3.3 Breach locations
Breach Location HAM1
Location of breach HAM1
| Breach Reference | HAM1 |
|---|---|
| Grid Reference | SU4845807111 |
| Description of location | Port Hamble Marina |
| Description of defence | Reinforced concrete wall |
| Source | Estuary/tidal river |
| Width of breach (m) | 20 |
| Seaward invert level (m AOD) | 0.2 |
| Inland invert level (m AOD) | 2.5 |
| Length of time breached (hrs) | 18 |
Breach Location HYT1
Location of breach HYT1