Animal accidents on New Forest roads can have devastating consequences for livestock and drivers alike - please stay alert and slow down

SD/003 Habitats Regulations Assessment – Regulation 19 Submission draft Local Plan

Summary

AI generated summary
Habitats Regulations Assessment of the New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan (2024–2043) at Regulation 19 stage. It reviews how proposed housing and other development could affect internationally protected nature sites (SACs, SPAs and Ramsar sites). Thirty-three sites within 20km were considered, with the New Forest and Solent sites most relevant. Screening found possible significant effects from development linked to urban-edge impacts, recreation pressure, water pollution and nutrient loading, water supply, air pollution from traffic, and impacts on mobile species, especially barbastelle bats linked to Mottisfont Bats SAC. These issues were assessed in detail and mitigation is built into the Plan, including restrictions near sensitive boundaries, strategic visitor-management schemes, nutrient neutrality requirements, project-level safeguards for specific allocations, reliance on water company plans, and ongoing air-quality monitoring with actions if problems arise. The report concludes the Plan will not harm the integrity of any protected site, alone or in combination.

Document Viewer

New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan HRA Report (Regulation 19 stage).

Durwyn Liley, Zoe Caals & Emily Rush

FOOTPRINT ECOLOGY, FOREST OFFICE, BERE ROAD, WAREHAM, DORSET BH20 7PA

WWW.FOOTPRINT - ECOLOGY.CO.UK

01929 552444

Footprint Ecology is a small, employee-owned, ecological consultancy with an ethical focus. Founded in 2004 and based in Purbeck, Dorset we are catalysts for change, collaborating with organisations that share our commitment to sustainability and social responsibility. We create practical solutions to complex ecological challenges across a diverse portfolio including nature conservation, outdoor recreation and associated strategic planning.

Footprint Contract Reference
863
Date
8th July 2026
Version
Final
Recommended Citation
Liley, D., Caals, Z. & Rush, E.(2026). New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan HRA (Regulation 19). Report by Footprint Ecology.

Summary

The Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017 (as amended) require local planning authorities to assess the impact of their local plan on the internationally important nature conservation sites in and around their administrative areas. The task is achieved by means of a Habitats Regulations Assessment (HRA). Sites that are relevant to the assessment are ‘European sites’ and include Special Areas of Conservation (SACs), Special Protection Areas (SPAs) and Ramsar sites.

These European sites are the top tier of protected sites in the UK and much of the National Park and adjacent areas are designated, reflecting the importance of the area for nature conservation. There are 33 European sites in total that are within the 20km radius, of which 11 sites are within or abut the National Park area. These include the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar which covers the heathland, woodland and wetland habitats of the New Forest (and a suite of associated species) and also the coastal areas (the Solent Maritime SAC, Solent & Isle of Wight Lagoons SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar).

An HRA asks very specific questions of a plan. Firstly, it ‘screens’ the plan to identify if there is a risk that certain policies or allocations may have a ‘likely significant effect’ on a European site, alone or (if necessary) in-combination with other plans and projects. If the risk of likely significant effects can be ruled out, then the plan may be adopted but if they cannot, the plan must be subjected to the greater scrutiny of an ‘appropriate assessment’. Following an appropriate assessment, a Plan may be adopted if an adverse effect on the integrity of the site can be ruled out, alone or in-combination with other plans or projects.

This document is the HRA of the New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan (at the Regulation 19 stage). It has been updated with each iteration of the Plan. All policies were subjected to a comprehensive screening and likely significant effects were identified in relation to the following types of impact and at least one European site:

  • General urban effects in relation to the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and Solent Maritime SAC and Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar (risks from the Plan alone)
  • Mobile species and functionally-linked land in relation to Mottisfont Bats SAC (risks from the Plan alone)
  • Recreation in relation to the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar (risks alone) and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC (risks from the Plan alone)
  • Water quality in relation to the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar, River Avon SAC (risks from the Plan alone);
  • Water quantity in relation to the New Forest SAC, New Forest Ramsar, River Itchen SAC and River Avon SAC (risks from the Plan in-combination);
  • Air quality and the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar (risks from the Plan in-combination).

Each of the above pathways have been taken to appropriate assessment and considered in detail. Following appropriate assessment, and taking into account mitigation measures incorporated into the Plan, it can be concluded that the Plan has no adverse effect on the integrity of any European site, alone or in-combination.

Contents

  • Summary ........................................................................................................................................ ii
  • Contents ........................................................................................................................................ iv
  • Acknowledgements ...................................................................................................................... v
  • 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 1
    • The New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan ....................................................... 1
    • Habitats Regulations Assessment process ...................................................................... 2
      • European sites .................................................................................................................... 2
      • Process ............................................................................................................................... 3
      • Definitions, references to case law and guidance .......................................................... 6
      • Role of the competent authority ..................................................................................... 8
    • Planning Reform .................................................................................................................. 8
  • 2. European sites in and around the New Forest ....................................................................... 9
    • Overlapping site boundaries ........................................................................................... 10
  • Potential impact pathways ....................................................................................................... 14
  • European sites and impact pathways ...................................................................................... 15
  • 3. Screening and the potential for Likely Significant Effects ..................................................... 23
    • Screening findings ............................................................................................................ 29
    • Habitat loss and land-take, including coastal squeeze ................................................. 29
    • General urban effects ....................................................................................................... 30
    • Mobile species and functionally linked land .................................................................. 30
    • Recreation ......................................................................................................................... 31
    • Water quality ..................................................................................................................... 32
    • Water quantity .................................................................................................................. 32
    • Air quality .......................................................................................................................... 33
  • 4. Appropriate assessment: General urban effects .................................................................. 34
    • Policies identified in the screening ................................................................................. 34
    • Overview of impact .......................................................................................................... 34
    • The New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar .................................................................................. 34
    • Solent Maritime SAC and Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar .......................... 38
  • 5. Appropriate assessment: Mobile species and impacts to functionally-linked land ............. 40
    • Policies identified in the screening ................................................................................. 40
    • Mottisfont Bats SAC ......................................................................................................... 40
  • 6. Appropriate assessment: Recreation .................................................................................... 44
    • Policies identified in the screening ................................................................................. 44
    • Overview of impact .......................................................................................................... 45
    • The New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar .................................................................................. 45
    • Impacts ............................................................................................................................. 45
    • Current visitor management ............................................................................................ 48
    • Strategic mitigation .......................................................................................................... 50
    • Solent and Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC ............... 51
    • Strategic mitigation .......................................................................................................... 52
  • 7. Appropriate assessment: Water quality ............................................................................... 54
    • Policies identified in the screening ................................................................................. 54
    • Wastewater and nutrient neutrality ................................................................................ 55
    • Individual allocations and issues with run-off and drainage ......................................... 58
  • 8. Appropriate assessment: Water quantity ............................................................................. 60
    • Policies identified in the screening ................................................................................. 60
    • Overview of impact .......................................................................................................... 60
    • River Basin Management Plans and role of the Environment Agency .......................... 60
    • Water companies ............................................................................................................. 61
  • 9. Appropriate assessment: Air quality .................................................................................... 64
    • Policies identified in the screening ................................................................................. 64
    • Overview of impact .......................................................................................................... 64
    • Findings from previous HRA work and more recent surveys ......................................... 65
    • Impact of proposed level of growth within the Plan ..................................................... 66
    • Mitigation ......................................................................................................................... 67
  • 10. Integrity test .......................................................................................................................... 70
  • References ................................................................................................................................. 73
  • Appendix 1: Summary of European sites ................................................................................. 79
  • Appendix 2: Screening for likely significant effects ................................................................. 96
  • Appendix 3: Distances to European sites and allocations ..................................................... 115

Acknowledgements

This report was commissioned by New Forest National Park Authority to support their forthcoming Local Plan. We are grateful to David Illsley for overseeing the work. Our thanks also to Ian Barker (New Forest National Park Authority) for useful comment and discussion.

1. Introduction

This document is a Habitat Regulations Assessment (HRA) report to accompany the New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan (‘the Plan’) at the publication plan stage (‘Regulation 19’). The report has been prepared by Footprint Ecology on behalf of New Forest National Park Authority. An HRA assesses the implications of a plan for European sites. The HRA will be finalised at the point at which the Plan is ready for adoption.

The New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan

The Plan sets planning policies and allocations to meet the needs across the National Park Authority area. It covers the period to 2043 in order to ensure provision for growth for 15 years upon adoption.

Work commenced to review and update the existing plan (adopted in 2019) in 2024 and follows on from the draft plan (Regulation 18) produced in 2025, to ensure that it remained consistent with the latest national planning policies, guidance and legislation. This also includes changes to the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) in late 2024.

The Plan has nine strategic objectives:

  1. Protect and enhance the natural capital and environment of the National Park, including the natural beauty of the landscape and the diverse range of habitats and species.
  2. Conserve and enhance the cultural heritage and historic environment of the National Park, especially the wealth of individual characteristics that contribute to its local distinctiveness.
  3. Plan for and adapt to the impacts of climate change on the landscape, species, character, cultural heritage, special qualities and communities of the New Forest, including energy-efficient development.
  4. Strengthen the health and well-being, identity and sustainability of rural communities and the pride of local people in their area.
  5. Promote appropriate housing to meet local needs, including the delivery of affordable housing for local people, to maintain the vibrant communities of the National Park.
  6. Develop a diverse and sustainable low carbon economy, enabling suitable rural diversification, that contributes to the well-being of local communities and supports a 'working forest', throughout the National Park.
  7. Encourage land management that both promotes and sustains traditional commoning practices to protect and enhance the special qualities of the National Park.
  8. Support proportionate development which encourages sustainable tourism and recreation, providing opportunities for enjoying the National Park without harming its special qualities or the welfare of its local communities.
  9. Reduce the impacts of traffic and enhance access to the National Park by supporting sustainable transport and active travel within the Park.

Habitats Regulations Assessment process

The designation, protection and restoration of European wildlife sites is embedded in the Conservation of Habitats and Species Regulations 2017, as amended, which are commonly referred to as the ‘Habitats Regulations’. These are domestic law and remain in place post-Brexit. The most recent amendments (the Conservation of Habitats and Species (amendment) (EU Exit) Regulations 20191) take account of the UKs departure from the EU.

Regulation 105 et seq addresses the assessment of local plans and determines the scope of this HRA alongside recent Government Guidance on the interpretation and application of the Regulations2.

European sites

‘European sites’ are those over which the provisions of the Habitat Regulations exert an influence, through statute or policy. They are the top tier of protected sites in the UK and are of international importance for nature conservation. Prior to Brexit, these were part of the Natura 2000 network of sites which formed the largest global network of protected sites.

Sites that are afforded statutory protection and included within regulation 8 of the Habitats Regulations are now part of the ‘national network’ and referred to as Habitats sites. Statutory sites comprise of the following:

  • Special Areas of Conservation (SACs) designated under the 1992 Habitats Directive;
  • Sites of Community Importance (SCI) included on the list of such sites compiled by the European Commission and submitted before the UK left the EU;
  • Candidate SACs (cSACs), submitted by the UK government to the European Commission before Exit day as eligible for selection as an SCI;
  • Special Protection Areas (SPAs) classified under the 1979 Birds Directive;
  • Potential SPAs (pSPAs) include potential sites as designated by the European Comission under the Conservation of Wild Birds Directive (2009);
  • Areas providing formal compensation for damage to a European site;
  • Ramsar sites (Wetlands of International Importance)3.

Process

HRA proceeds through a step-by-step process, summarised in Figure 1. Throughout all stages, there is a continual consideration of the options available to avoid and mitigate any identified potential impacts. A competent authority may consider that there is a need to undertake further levels of evidence gathering and evaluation at the appropriate assessment stage in order to provide the necessary certainty. At this point the competent authority may identify the need to add to or modify the plan in order to adequately protect the European site, and these mitigation measures may be added through the imposition of particular restrictions and conditions.

For plans, the stages of HRA are often quite fluid, with the plan normally being prepared by the competent authority itself. This gives the competent authority the opportunity to repeatedly explore options to prevent impacts, refine the plan and rescreen it to demonstrate that all potential risks to European sites have been successfully dealt with.

When preparing a plan, a competent authority may therefore go through a continued assessment as the plan develops, enabling the assessment to inform the development of the plan. For example, a competent authority may choose to pursue an amended or different option where impacts can be avoided, rather than continue to assess an option that has the potential to significantly affect European site interest features.

After completing an assessment, a competent authority should only adopt a plan where it can be ascertained that there will not be an adverse effect on the integrity of the European site(s) in question. In order to reach this conclusion, the competent authority may have made changes to the plan, or modified the project with restrictions or conditions, in light of their Appropriate Assessment findings.

Where adverse effects cannot be ruled out, further exceptional tests are set out in Regulation 107. In exceptional cases, this allows a plan to be taken forward where there are no ‘alternative solutions’, where ‘imperative reasons of overriding public interest’ apply and where compensation can be delivered. It should be noted that meeting these tests is a rare last resort and ordinarily, competent authorities seek to ensure that a plan or project is fully mitigated for, or it does not proceed.

In such circumstances where a competent authority considers that a plan should proceed under Regulations 107, they must notify the relevant Secretary of State. Normally, planning decisions and competent authority duties are then transferred, becoming the responsibility of the Secretary of State, unless on considering the information, the planning authority is directed by the Secretary of State to make their own decision on the plan or project at the local level. The decision maker, whether the Secretary of State or the planning authority, should give full consideration to any proposed ‘overriding reasons’ for which a plan or project should proceed despite being unable to rule out adverse effects on European site interest features, and ensure that those reasons are in the public interest and are such that they override the potential harm. The decision maker will also need to secure any necessary compensatory measures, to ensure the continued overall coherence of the European site network if such a plan or project is allowed to proceed. However, it is understood that the National Park Authority would not wish to pursue these derogations.

Figure 1: Flow chart illustrating the four-stage process of HRAs for plans. Adapted from Tyldesley & Chapman (2013).

Definitions, references to case law and guidance

This HRA follows principles of case law, both UK and EU. We follow relevant government guidance4 and also draw on the Habitats Regulations Assessment Handbook (Tyldesley and Chapman, 2013), which while no longer updated provides useful background and context.

The flow chart (Figure 1) includes a number of key terms which it is useful to clarify and define. At the beginning of the process, a plan can be exempted if it is directly connected with or necessary to the management of a European site. It can also be excluded from further assessment if it is not a plan (or a project) and eliminated from the HRA process is it is obvious that it could not have any conceivable adverse effect on any European site.

In Stage 1, a ‘likely significant effect’ following Waddenzee5, is a ‘possible significant effect; one whose occurrence cannot be excluded on the basis of objective information’. It is a low threshold and simply means that there is a risk or doubt regarding such an effect. The screening stage is a preliminary examination, sometimes described as a coarse filter, or following Sweetman6, as ‘a trigger for the obligation to carry out an appropriate assessment’. There should however be credible evidence to show that there is a real rather than a hypothetical risk of effects that could undermine a site’s conservation objectives. This was amplified in the Bagmoor Wind7 case where ‘if the absence of risk... can only be demonstrated after a detailed investigation, or expert opinion, [then] the authority must move from preliminary examination to appropriate assessment’.

Following the People Over Wind judgement8, when making screening decisions for the purposes of deciding whether an appropriate assessment is required, competent authorities cannot take into account any measures intended to avoid or reduce harmful effects upon a European site.

Stage 2 involves the appropriate assessment and integrity test. Here a plan can only be adopted if the competent authority can demonstrate that it will not adversely affect the integrity of the European site. This is precautionary approach and means it is necessary to show the absence of harm.

Following Champion9 ‘appropriate’ is not a technical term but simply indicates that the assessment needs to be appropriate to the task in hand.

The integrity of a European site has been described as the ‘coherence of its ecological structure and function, across its whole area, that enables it to sustain the habitat, complex of habitats and/or the levels of populations of the species for which it was classified10. An alternative definition, after Sweetman11, is ‘the lasting preservation of the constitutive characteristics of the site’.

In terms of the burden of proof, the HRA of development plans was first made a requirement in the UK following a ruling by the European Court of Justice in EC v UK12. However, the judgement13 recognised that any assessment had to reflect the actual stage in the strategic planning process and the level of evidence that might or might not be available. This was given expression in the High Court (Feeney)14 which stated: “Each … assessment … cannot do more than the level of detail of the strategy at that stage permits”.

The need to consider possible in-combination effects arises at stage 1 – the screening and also at stage 2 – the appropriate assessment and integrity test. The effects of the plan in-combination with other plans or projects are the cumulative effects which will or might arise from the addition of the effects of other relevant plans or projects alongside the plan under consideration. If during the stage 1 screening it is found the subject plan would have no likely effect alone but might have such an effect in-combination, then the appropriate assessment at stage 2 will proceed to consider cumulative effects. Where a plan is screened as having a likely significant effect alone, the appropriate assessment should initially concentrate on its effects alone.

Role of the competent authority

Although this HRA has been prepared to help the National Park Authority discharge its duties under the Habitats Regulations, the National Park Authority is the competent authority, and it must decide whether to accept this report or otherwise. Further, it should be noted that this HRA has been prepared for the purposes of preparing and examining the Plan. Individual allocations will need to be reviewed when they become the subject of an individual planning application, to ensure that if further assessment under the Habitats Regulations is necessary, it is undertaken in accordance with the requirements of appropriate assessment.

Planning Reform

The UK government has set ambitious targets for house building over the current parliament. The Planning and Infrastructure Act15, enacted in December 2025, is proposed to speed up and streamline the delivery of new homes, with a focus on strategic mitigation to enable development. The Act establishes Natural England (as the delivery body) responsible for the production and administration of Environmental Delivery Plans (EDPs), determining standardised levels of environmental mitigation needed for certain types and scales of development in a specific area. At the time of writing, EDPs will initially focus on nutrient related issues such as water and air quality but there is scope in the future for these to cover a wider range of issues such as recreation, individual species and other sensitive features.

Until EDPs are adopted in a given area it is important that New Forest National Park Authority (as the competent authority) ensures necessary assessment work is undertaken and that, where required, strategic mitigation schemes are in place to address the impacts of development. The Plan will need to be assessed in light of the legislation and legal requirements in place at the time, and as such it is necessary to ensure all impacts are identified in the early stages of the Plan and necessary mitigation identified and secured.


  1. The amending regulations generally seek to retain the requirements of the 2017 Regulations but with adjustments for the UK’s exit from the European Union. See Regulation 4, which also confirms that the interpretation of these Regulations as they had effect, or any guidance as it applied, before exit day, shall continue to do so.
  2. Habitats regulations assessments: protecting a European site. Defra and Natural England. 24 February 2021. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/habitats-regulations-assessments-protecting-a-european-site
  3. The Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 extended protections in the Habitats Regulations to provide statutory protection for Ramsar sites; previously these had been only afforded protection through long-established policy and the NPPF.
  4. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/habitats-regulations-assessments-protecting-a-european-site
  5. Waddenzee: European Courts C-127/02 Waddenzee 7th September 2004, reference for a preliminary ruling from the Raad van State.
  6. Sweetman: European Court C – 258/11 Sweetman 11th April 2013, reference for a preliminary ruling from the Supreme Court of Ireland
  7. Bagmoor Wind: UK courts Bagmoor Wind v The Scottish Ministers, Court of Session [2012] CSIH 93
  8. People Over Wind and Sweetman v Coillte Teoranta (323-17) [2018] PTSR 1668
  9. R (on the application of Champion v North Norfolk District Council) [2015] 1 WLR 3170 at para 41
  10. Para 20 of the ODPM Circ. 06/2005
  11. Sweetman v An Bord Pleanála (C–258-11) [2014] PTSR 1092 at paragraph 39
  12. Commission v UK (C-6/04) [2005] ECR 1-9017
  13. Commission of the European Communities v UK Opinion of Advocate General Kokott
  14. Feeney v Oxford City Council [2011] EWHC 2699 Admin at paragraph 92
  15. The Planning and Infrastructure Act received Royal Assent on 18th December 2025, see https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/3946 for background and details.

2. European sites in and around the New Forest

We have used a 20km boundary from the National Park boundary as an initial area of search (20km providing a reasonable area within which policies could reasonably be considered to generate measurable effects). Air quality impacts at plan level are typically considered to relate to a 10km distance (Chapman and Kite, 2021) while generic analysis of Footprint Ecology visitor data to countryside sites in the UK (Weitowitz et al., 2019) indicates that the majority of visitors originate within a 12.6km radius16. The choice of 20km is therefore precautionary.

Sites that fall within this initial area of search are listed in Table 1 and shown in Map 1 (SACs), Map 2 (SPAs) and Map 3 (Ramsar). There are 33 European sites in total that are within the 20km radius, of which 11 sites are within or abut the National Park area. All 33 sites are also listed in Appendix 1, which gives the relevant qualifying features and other site background, including links to the conservation objectives for each site.

Table 1: European sites within 20km of the New Forest National Park boundary

Those where no distance is given lie within or partly within the boundary. 20km reflects the distance we normally use to identify sites that might be relevant for the screening, recognising that many of these will then be eliminated from further consideration.

European site Distance to NFNPA boundary (km)
SACs
Briddlesford Copses10.7
Dorset Heaths0.8
Dorset Heaths (Purbeck & Wareham) & Studland Dunes17.4
Emer Bog7.3
Great Yews6.1
Isle of Wight Downs4.1
Isle of Portland to Studland Cliffs18.6
Mottisfont Bats5.8
Prescombe Down18.0
River Avon-
River Itchen6.6
Salisbury Plain11.6
Solent & Isle of Wight Lagoons-
Solent Maritime-
South Wight Maritime3.8
Studland to Portland17.8
The New Forest SAC-
SPAs
Avon Valley-
Chichester & Langstone Harbours18.2
Dorset Heathlands0.8
Poole Harbour14.8
Porton Down12.4
Portsmouth Harbour8.9
Solent & Southampton Water-
Solent & Dorset Coast-
The New Forest SPA-
Ramsar
Avon Valley-
Chichester & Langstone Harbours18.2
Dorset Heathlands0.8
Poole Harbour15.4
Portsmouth Harbour8.9
Solent & Southampton Water-
The New Forest Ramsar-

Overlapping site boundaries

The Dorset Heaths comprise a series of different heathland patches, from just to the east of Dorchester to the Hampshire boundary. These cover some 40 different SSSIs and multiple European sites. Where relevant and for simplicity, we use ‘Dorset Heaths SAC/SPA/Ramsar’ as an umbrella term for the following European sites: Dorset Heaths SAC; Dorset Heathlands SPA; and Dorset Heathlands Ramsar, noting that the boundaries of these sites are not necessarily all contiguous.

Similarly, we refer to the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar when referring to the New Forest sites combined. It should be noted that the SAC, SPA and Ramsar site boundaries are not the same, but largely cover the same area.


16 Note this is a generic figure from an analysis of visitor survey data from across the UK. Specific data are available for some European sites and these referenced at the relevant point in the HRA.

Potential impact pathways

Drawing on the background information relating to European sites, potential impact pathways, i.e. ways in which elements of the Plan might conceivably impact on the relevant European sites and trigger likely significant effects, could include:

  • Habitat loss and land-take, including coastal squeeze, i.e. the direct loss of land within European sites with coastal squeeze an issue for coastal sites with habitats such as saltmarsh. Relevant for European sites within National Park where development could result in loss of habitat;
  • General urban effects, covering impacts associated with development in very close proximity to European sites, through for example light pollution, noise, domestic cats, spread of garden waste and invasive species etc. This pathway would only be relevant where European sites are within the National Park boundary. Also only relates to sites with existing boundaries with extensive urban fringe or qualfying features potentially vulnerable to cat predation (e.g. heathland birds, herptiles);
  • Mobile species and impacts to functionally-linked land, i.e. impacts to supporting habitat (loss of land or change of use) or risks for species moving outside European site boundaries (e.g. where lighting or development hinders movement). Relevant species are potentially Marsh Fritillary, bats, Nightjar, Great-crested Newt, migratory fish, waterbirds);
  • Recreation, covering impacts relating to public access to sensitive areas, including disturbance, increased fire risk and contamination from dogs. Relevant where sites are accessible to the public and the accessible areas include habitats vulnerable to recreation/fire, such as heathland, chalk grassland, reedbeds, vegetated shingle, sand dunes or particular species (ground-nesting birds, colonial waterbirds, Dartford Warbler, wintering waterbirds etc.);
  • Water quality, covering the impacts from increased nutrients and pollution and relevant for European sites with water-dependent qualifying features and a catchment within the National Park;
  • Water quantity, covering impacts relating to abstraction of water and a reduction in the amount of water available, relevant for European sites with water-dependent qualifying features;
  • Air quality, covering the impacts of air pollution including those associated with increased traffic. Relevant to European sites with roads within 200m and qualifying features potentially vulnerable to changes in air quality. When considering air quality impacts, a process contribution of 1% of the relevant critical load or level, either alone or in combination with other plans or projects, is usually used to identify an effect as potentially significant.

These are simplified, umbrella terms to facilitate screening and simplify a range of complex issues. The European sites have different qualifying features and as such impacts are relevant for different sites. The local geography and distance from the National Park boundary to the European sites will also determine which sites are vulnerable in which ways.

European sites and impact pathways

Potential impact pathways are summarised by European site in Table 2. This table provides the context for the screening for likely significant effects and shows which sites could be relevant and the pathways that need to be the focus when screening the Plan.

It can be seen that all impact pathways are potentially relevant for at least one European site and that the following European sites are the only ones for which there could be any credible impact pathway (and will therefore form the focus for the screening):

  • Dorset Heaths SAC/SPA/Ramsar
  • Mottisfont Bats SAC
  • River Avon SAC
  • River Itchen SAC
  • Solent Maritime SAC
  • The New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar
  • Avon Valley SPA/Ramsar
  • Portsmouth Harbour SPA/Ramsar
  • Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar
  • Solent & Dorset Coast SPA

The table also helps eliminate European sites that do not need further consideration as – due to their location, interest feature or other characteristics there is no credible way they could be impacted by the Plan. The pale grey shading in the table indicates these sites are there are 16 European sites that need no further consideration within the HRA.

3. Screening and the potential for Likely Significant Effects

The screening is stage one of the four-stage process and is the point at which the plan is checked for likely significant effects. With a Local Plan the screening is usually a policy-by-policy check to ensure all elements of the Plan are considered in the context of the Habitat Regulations. Any areas of concern will then be examined in more detail at the appropriate assessment stage (stage two) of the Habitat Regulations process. In the previous section we have identified the relevant European sites and the potential impact pathways that be relevant to those sites – this facilitates the screening by setting out the different things that need to be checked.

The screening has been undertaken based on a draft of the Plan shared by the NFNPA in May 2026. Map 4 shows the potential development that would come forward as a result of the Plan. Sites that are shown in dark brown are ones carried forward from the 2019 local plan. The distance from all allocations to all European sites is provided in Appendix 3. As Map 4 illustrates, many of the allocations are towards the eastern side of the National Park.

Some of the sites carried forward have been granted full planning permissions and these are identified in the screening table (Appendix 2). These have already been subject to project level assessment are not re-assessed individually; however the cumulative effects of these sites are included in the overarching policies setting out the quantum and distribution of growth.

In undertaking the screening we have drawn upon the following geographic criteria, based on existing evidence or mitigation strategies:

  • Likely significant effects from urban effects for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar triggered if proposal relates to residential development within 400m of any of the SAC/SPA/Ramsar boundary (see Fearnley et al., 2012 for background and context);
  • Likely significant effects from recreation for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar triggered if proposal relates to residential or tourist development anywhere within the National Park boundary (as the entire National Park is within the 13.8km zone of influence);
  • Likely significant effects for recreation for the Dorset Heaths SAC/SPA/Ramsar triggered if proposal relates to residential or tourist overnight development within a 5km buffer from the SAC/SPA/Ramsar boundary (see Map 5)17;
  • Likely significant effects for recreation and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC triggered if proposal relates to residential or tourist overnight development within a 5.6km buffer from the SPA/Ramsar boundary (see Map 5)18;
  • Likely significant effects for water quality for the Solent European sites or the River Avon SAC triggered if proposal relates to overnight accommodation within the relevant catchment (see Map 6)19;
  • Likely significant effects for air quality only possible where roads are within 10km and where there are roads within 200m of the European site (see Map 7, which for context shows all roads within 200m of a European site within 10km of the National Park boundary).

  1. See Dorset Heaths planning framework for background and context: https://www.dorsetcouncil.gov.uk/w/dorset-heathlands-planning-framework
  2. See Bird Aware Solent strategy for background to zone: https://birdaware.org/solent/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2025/03/Bird-Aware-Solent-Revised-Strategy-September-2024.pdf we have used the 5.6km buffer to also identify likely significant effects in relation to the Solent Maritime SAC.
  3. For further information on the catchment maps see the Natural England website: https://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/publication/4982167238344704 and https://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/publication/6522945605468160

Screening findings

The screening identifies which individual policies and the relevant European sites which should be taken forward to appropriate assessment.

Likely significant effects was identified for one or more European sites for the following policies, alone or in-combination:

  • SP3: Spatial Strategy;
  • SP5: Land to the north of Fawley Waterside;
  • SP29: New residential development in the National Park;
  • SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital;
  • SP34: Land at Knellers Lane, Ashurst;
  • SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue, Lyndhurst;
  • SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway;
  • SP39: Land to west of Winsor Road, Winsor;
  • SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford;
  • SP41: Land to the east of The Ridge, Redlynch;
  • SP50: Allocation of land at Ringwood Road, Netley Marsh for Travelling Showpeople’s use.

In addition, Policy SP11: Nature conservation sites of international importance was also screened in as it is a bespoke policy intended to avoid or reduce harmful effects on a European site and sets out mitigation measures that need to be considered at appropriate assessment.

Findings for each impact pathway are summarised below.

Habitat loss and land-take, including coastal squeeze

The Plan contains no policies or allocations that would result in land take from any European site and therefore direct habitat loss can be ruled out as an impact pathway. New development could pose risks in terms of a need to retain and maintain existing sea defences that might otherwise be planned for decline and breaching over time and can also strongly support the building of new defences. Likely significant effects can be ruled out for coastal squeeze as the only allocation that could pose such a risk is Policy SP5: Land to the north of Fawley Waterside. Checks of the relevant Shoreline Management Plan (SMP)20 indicate the intention to Hold the Line (HTL) and the area is therefore not currently intended as an area where the sea defences might be allowed to breach. Any loss of intertidal habitat (such as saltmarsh) within the Solent Maritime SAC or the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar is therefore addressed through the SMP (which is subject to its own HRA). This HRA is therefore in a sense ‘shielded’ by the SMP process and the HTL intention. The Local Plan includes no requirement build or maintain physical defences.

General urban effects

Policies SP3: Spatial Strategy and SP29: New residential development in the National Park have both been screened in alone for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar with risks such as cat predation, invasive species etc. resulting from development in close proximity.

Allocations that have not already been granted planning permission were also screened in alone for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, where they are within 400m. Relevant allocations were SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital; SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue, Lyndhurst and SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway.

In addition, Policy SP5: Land to north of Fawley Waterside was screened in alone for the Solent Maritime SAC and Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar with risks from invasive species, noise etc. resulting from development in close proximity.

No likely significant effects were identified with respect to urban effects and the River Avon SAC as all allocations and Defined Villages are well away from the river (well beyond 400m).

Mobile species and functionally linked land

Policies SP3: Spatial Strategy and SP29: New residential development in the National Park were both screened in alone for the Mottisfont Bats SAC as new development (particularly to the north of the National Park at Landford and Redlynch) may pose risks to flight lines and foraging areas for Barbastelle associated with the Mottisfont Bats SAC. In addition, SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford screened in alone for the Mottisfont Bats SAC, with possible risks around lighting, disruption to flight lines as a result of development and loss of woodland habitat.

No risks for the waterbirds associated with the Solent and Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar have been identified as allocations and Defined Villages are well away from any areas of possible foraging habitat including locations within the Solent and Brent Goose mitigation strategy (Liley and Sharp, 2010; Whitfield and Marceau, 2024), with the exception of SP5, and checks of aerial imagery indicate the allocation does not contain suitable habitat for wintering waterbirds. No likely significant effects were identified for the River Avon SAC as the Plan contains no development or proposals that might affect the river/water course or movement of species (e.g. weirs).

Recreation

The whole of the National Park is within the 13.8km zone of influence for recreation impacts for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and therefore all net new dwellings and any forms of overnight accommodation are screened in. Policies SP3: Spatial Strategy and SP29: New residential development in the National Park were both screened in alone as these policies set the overall quantum of growth. All new allocations and those carried forward (but yet to be granted planning permission) were also screened in, in-combination: SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital; SP34: Land at Knellers Lane, Ashurst; SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue, Lyndhurst; SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway; SP39 Land to west of Winsor Road, Winsor; SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford; SP41: Land to the east of The Ridge, Redlynch and SP50: Allocation of land at Ringwood Road, Netley Marsh for Travelling Showpeople’s use.

Policies SP3: Spatial Strategy and SP29: New residential development in the National Park were both screened in alone for the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC with risks from increased recreation use associated with new housing. New allocations and those carried forward (but yet to be granted planning permission) were also screened in, for in-combination effects, if within the 5.6km zone of influence: SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital; SP34: Land at Knellers Lane; SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway and SP39: Land to west of Winsor Road, Winsor.

Policy SP11: Nature conservation sites of international importance was also screened in, with respect to both the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar as it is a bespoke policy intended to avoid or reduce harmful effects on a European site and sets out mitigation measures that need to be considered at appropriate assessment.

No likely significant effects were identified with respect to recreation and the River Avon SAC or Avon Valley SPA/Ramsar as all allocations and Defined Villages are well away from the river and any access points, or the gravel pits associated with the SPA/Ramsar. No allocations or Defined Villages are within the 5km zone of influence for the Dorset Heaths SAC/SPA/Ramsar and therefore no likely significant effects were recognised for the Dorset Heaths.

Water quality

Policies SP3: Spatial Strategy and SP29: New residential development in the National Park were both screened in alone for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the River Avon SAC, with risks from wastewater discharge and nutrient neutrality. It should be noted that none of the defined villages or proposed housing site allocations are within the catchment of the River Avon SAC, and as such risks for the latter SAC are particularly low. Likely significant effects were also identified in-combination for all allocations (excluding those already granted planning permission) and the Solent Maritime SAC, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar: SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital; SP34: Land at Knellers Lane, Ashurst; SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue, Lyndhurst; SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway; SP39: Land to west of Winsor Road, Bartley; SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford and SP41: Land to the east of The Ridge, Redlynch.

In addition: SP5: Land to north of Fawley Waterside was screened in alone for water quality and Solent Maritime SAC, Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar due to risks associated with run-off (including during construction).

SP3: Spatial Strategy, SP29: New residential development in the National Park and the following allocations (either new or those not yet granted planning permission) were screened in alone in relation to water quality and the New Forest SAC and the New Forest Ramsar due to risks from run-off: SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital; SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway.

Water quantity

Policies SP3: Spatial Strategy and SP29: New residential development in the National Park were screened in for in-combination effects in relation to the New Forest SAC, New Forest Ramsar, River Itchen SAC and River Avon SAC in relation to water quantity. Given the scale and distribution of growth these are the only European sites with water dependent features where risks from water quantity are relevant. All new allocations and those yet to be granted planning permission are also screened in, in-combination, with respect to water quantity and the same European sites.

Air quality

Air quality modelling work to generate process contribution data for the allocations within the Plan, in-combination with growth in surrounding areas (including BCP and New Forest District) is a significant undertaking and was not available to inform this HRA. Policies SP3: Spatial Strategy and SP29: New residential development in the National Park were therefore both screened in, in-combination for air quality and the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar. There are numerous roads that cross the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and any new residential development within the Plan is likely to affect traffic on these roads. All new allocations and those yet to be granted planning permission were also screened in, in-combination, with respect to air quality and the same European sites.

Likely significant effects were ruled out for all other European sites with respect to air quality, due to the levels of growth proposed and geography of the road network and European sites in relation to the distribution of growth proposed in the Plan.

Given that all the allocations are to the east and south of the National Park and the Defined Villages are in the north and north-east of the National Park, there are no likely significant effects for the Dorset Heaths SAC/SPA/Ramsar in relation to air quality. Routes such as the A31 Ringwood Road near Avon Heath, which has heathland adjacent to it, are too far outside the authority for there to be risks for the Dorset Heaths. Similarly, the easterly focus for the allocations, limited lengths of road within 200m (most roads within this distance cross it rather than run parallel) means risks can be ruled out for the River Avon SAC. The Mottisfont Bat SAC is bisected by a minor road but given layout of the road network and the SAC being nearly 6km from the New Forest boundary, there is no risk from the quantum of growth proposed. No likely significant effects are identified for the River Itchen SAC and air quality from roads either, given the site’s distance from the National Park and scale of growth proposed. For the Solent sites (Solent Maritime SAC, Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar) the tidal cycle and constant flushing will reduce the impacts of air quality and the only roads within 200m on the west side of Southampton Water are lanes set back from the saltmarsh by fields, given the growth proposed in the Plan there are no likely significant effects.


20 See https://www.northsolentsmp.co.uk/; relevant section in the SMP is SC14 which runs from Redbridge to Calshot Spit

4. Appropriate assessment: General urban effects

Policies identified in the screening

Likely significant effects were identified for the following policies from the screening:

  • SP3: Spatial Strategy (likely significant effects alone for New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP5: Land to north of Fawley Waterside (likely significant effects alone for the Solent Maritime SAC and Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP29: New residential development in the National Park (likely significant effects alone for New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital (likely significant effects alone for New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue, Lyndhurst (likely significant effects alone for New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway (likely significant effects alone for New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);

Overview of impact

General urban effects relate to sites where development has been situated close to the boundary of European sites. Potential impacts relate to light and noise pollution, cat predation, fly tipping and overspill of garden waste, spread of invasive species and vandalism. Informal access points can be created where gardens directly touch a European site boundary. As such there are some overlaps with urban effects and recreation.

Mitigation approaches such as access management and wardening are likely to be less relevant to development in close proximity to European sites as it is harder to intercept visitors who enter from multiple informal access points (e.g. back gardens) and are likely to use the heath at a wide range of times of day (and even during the night). Such use will be by people who have the greenspace literally on their doorstep – their de facto space to use and potentially seen as an extension to their garden. That will differ from the use by people who travel to the site and make an effort to visit, potentially driving and arriving at a main car-park.

The New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar

With respect to the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the principal concerns relating to urban effects are:

  • Cat predation;
  • Increased fire risk (e.g. from bonfires, bbqs etc.);
  • Spread of invasive plants and other species/pests etc from gardens;
  • Noise pollution (resulting in disturbance);
  • Light pollution.

There are also potential issues around new residents trying to influence the area around the gardens or access, for example in terms of tidying (e.g. deadwood) or interactions with grazing animals (e.g. around gardens).

These impacts all relate to development in very close proximity. Some of the issues with the more urban heaths in Dorset and Hampshire – such as arson, people building bike jumps, motorbikes etc – are perhaps more associated with the urban environment and are less of a concern in the New Forest.

We have used 400m as a guide to determine where there are risks of urban effects and screen-in allocations. The choice of 400m is a pragmatic one, reflecting the exclusion zone (i.e. assumption against growth established in policy or strategic mitigation strategy) used around other heathland sites such as the Dorset Heaths and the Thames Basin Heaths. It should also be noted that in some areas such as around Burnham Beeches SAC and around the Chilterns Beechwoods SAC at Ashridge, a strict 500m zone is applied, while at some sites such as Epping Forest SAC, development within 400m of the SAC is assessed on a case-by-case basis (see Beveridge et al., 2024 for summary).

Risks decrease with distance (i.e. the closer to the European site, the greater the risk), and there is no clear cut-off point at which risks no longer occur. For example there are many studies of the home ranges of cats (see Hall et al., 2016 for meta-analysis and review) and these show varying results, reflecting great variability between individual cats and different locations. The study by Kays et. al (2020) indicates that most pet cats have very small ranges and stay within 100m of their home (noting that some in the same study were also recorded over 1km from their home). Some studies from the UK indicate 300-400m as an exclusory limit for cats (Thomas, Baker and Fellowes, 2014; Pirie, Thomas and Fellowes, 2022), and the study by Pirie et al. provides evidence that cats associated with houses on urban boundaries (e.g. where heathland abuts housing) have much larger home ranges. As such 400m seems a sensible distance to use with respect to cats.

For other impacts, such as the prevalence of plants that have spread from adjacent gardens or the impacts of noise from houses and gardens on species of conservation concern, there is relatively little evidence for the specific distances at which risks occur and where any cut-off point might be.

A report in 2012 for the National Park Authority (Fearnley et al., 2012) considered the risks from disturbance and urban effects in more detail. The report highlights the challenges of applying a 400m zone in the New Forest, given the complex shape of the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and the fact that it comprises a very large extensive block of semi-natural habitat which surrounds some small settlements such as Brockenhurst and Lyndhurst. This is essentially the opposite of the situation in Dorset where there are small, fragmented heaths surrounded by housing. Development within the New Forest is also highly constrained due to the extent of designated sites and planning constraints within the National Park, and as such the scale of urban development that has occurred around some heathland areas (such as in Dorset and the Thames Basin) will not occur. This reduces the risks from cumulative effects. Nonetheless the risks from development in close proximity cannot be discounted and it is necessary to have a clearly defined and robust approach.

The Plan follows the approach established in the adopted plan, where any allocations where the boundary fell within 400m of the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar were either designed so that any development was at least 400m from the European site boundary or restricted in use to C2 type use (care homes etc). Risks from urban effects are less with care homes as pet ownership is likely to be limited and residents are unlikely to stray beyond the grounds of the care home. Natural England, in their submission to the hearing for adopted plan in 201821 confirmed that certain types of C2 residential accommodation (e.g. purpose-built schemes for the frail elderly) could take place within 400m of the heaths.

The Plan allocates 3 sites that are within 400m. SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital has been carried forward from the previous plan. Planning permission was granted in 202622. It is for Class C2 care home or extra care use, with built development confined to previously developed land and mitigation incorporated into site design to ensure a buffer to the designated site boundary. Natural England raised no objection to the application, subject to a series of mitigation measures being secured, including:

  • The care home is to be restricted to C2 use, with a no pet policy and parking restrictions. These measures are to be secured for the life time of the development by an appropriate worded condition.
  • Details of proposed mitigation measures to address any nutrient impacts, including appropriately funded management and monitoring, and details of how the measures will be secured for the lifetime of the development.
  • Details of planting scheme and ongoing maintenance to strengthen the boundary buffer, and protect the New Forest designated sites from urban edge effects to be secured within an appropriate worded condition.

SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue is within Lyndhurst and there are existing houses and development between the allocation and the SAC/SPA/National Park. The main edge to the allocation faces open grassland away from the European site and the allocation is for C2 care home, nursing home or extra care housing.

The SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road allocation at Sway is also allocated for C2 or extra care housing and policy wording requires a landscaped buffer to the north of the site (which abuts the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar) and – once detailed design elements are available – information on how any remaining urban edge impacts will be addressed.

Policy SP3 and SP29 set out the overall housing numbers and how these will be delivered. 285 dwellings will be on allocated sites and a further 380 will be windfall. It is not possible to ascertain whether any of these windfall sites might come forward within 400m. Case by case assessment will be necessary and wording in the Plan at paragraph 6.14 and accompanying footnote (supporting text of Policy SP11) is clear that the applicant will need to provide sufficient evidence for an appropriate assessment (that is in turn informed by this HRA). In general, in line with the approach taken above for allocations, it is likely to be possible to rule out adverse effects on integrity on the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar for any windfall proposal within 400m if it relates to C2 type use (care homes etc). Each application will need to considered separately and as windfall (by its nature) will be small in scale and localised, cumulative effects are limited.

In addition, Policy SP11 provides a protective policy with respect to European sites; the wording is clear that development may not always be possible:

Avoidance or mitigation may not be possible in some cases due to the impacts, scale, type, or proximity of the proposed development in relation to the designated site, and so the Authority will assess each case on its merits.

The general protection afforded by SP11 is important as it ensures development will be checked and any unallocated windfall sites are not able to come forward unless adverse effects on integrity can be ruled out at project level HRA. Monitoring (see Section 11 of the Plan, under Objective 1) includes levels of windfall with the aim of ensuring potential urban edge impacts within 400m are mitigated.

There is no scope for in-combination effects as the New Forest National Park Authority boundary encompasses almost all areas within 400m of the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar.

Solent Maritime SAC and Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar

Policy SP5: Land to north of Fawley Waterside is an employment allocation relatively close (235m) from the saltmarsh of Southampton Water. The allocation abuts the European site boundary and urban effects are therefore possible, for example:

  • Increased noise (disturbance to birds);
  • Light pollution (disturbance to birds);
  • Spread of invasive plant species;
  • Litter.

Given the employment uses, location and distance from key areas within the European site, risks are potentially relatively slight, but will depend on the type of use and layout of the site. The policy wording ensures that a masterplan will be produced that sets out all necessary mitigation alongside the layout, planting etc. These elements will need to be assessed at project level and the wording ensures the necessary steps and protective wording are in place.

Given the low risks, mitigation will be achievable but will be dependent on detailed site design and further information, as such it is necessary to defer to a lower-tier assessment. Project level assessment will be able to identify more precisely the nature, scale and types of urban effects that may be relevant and there will be flexibility in the site design and proposal to enable an adverse effect on site integrity to be mitigated or avoided.

Conclusions: General urban effects

There are three allocations (SP33, SP35 and SP38) that are within 400m of the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar; both are for C2 care home use, as opposed to C3 residential use and policy wording ensures measures to mitigate urban edge effects are incorporated where relevant. Any unallocated windfall sites that come forward within 400m will need to be subject to appropriate assessment and the need for this is set out in Policy SP11. Supporting text to SP11 (para 6.14) sets out the need for appropriate assessment in relation to urban edge effects. This approach, in line with the current (adopted plan), along with the very low level of growth and with the overall protection and need for further assessment set out in SP11, ensure all risks are addressed and adverse effects on integrity can be ruled out from the Plan alone. There is no scope for in-combination effects given that the New Forest National Park Authority boundary encompasses almost all areas within 400m.

A further allocation, SP5 is within 400m of Solent Maritime SAC & the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar. This allocation is for employment use only and policy wording ensures a masterplan will be produced that sets out all necessary mitigation alongside the layout, planting etc. Further checks at project level eliminate risks and allow a conclusion of no adverse effects on integrity.


  1. Dated 20 November 2018
  2. SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital has been carried forward from the previous plan. Planning application 22/00548 was granted in March 2026 – see Citizen Portal Planning - application details for further details. The planning consent was a hybrid consent with outline planning application (all matters reserved except for access) for an up to 70 bed care home; and full planning consent granted for an extension to the Snowden Centre building for healthcare purposes.

5. Appropriate assessment: Mobile species and impacts to functionally-linked land

Policies identified in the screening

Likely significant effects were identified for the following policies from the screening:

  • SP3: Spatial Strategy (likely significant effects alone for the Mottisfont Bats SAC);
  • SP29: New residential development in the National Park (likely significant effects alone for the Mottisfont Bats SAC);
  • SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford (likely significant effects alone for the Mottisfont Bats SAC).

Mottisfont Bats SAC

Mottisfont SAC qualifies for Barbastelle Bat, one of England’s rarest bats. Natural England’s supplementary conservation advice indicates that trees in the woodlands at Mottisfont are used as a summer maternity roost, with the bats showing a preference toward roosting in deciduous, hardwood trees, particularly Oak, Beech and Sweet Chestnut. The bats also use the site as a foraging area and have known navigation routes through the woodland to (predominantly) riverine areas and subsequent feeding areas in the surrounding landscape.

The supplementary conservation advice states that the bats forage widely, up to 7km from their maternity roosts, though apparently some individuals may forage further to reach suitable feeding grounds. The advice suggests that Barbastelles prefer pastoral landscapes with deciduous woodland, wet meadows and waterbodies, and will also feed in more open areas such as orchards. In order to reach these foraging areas Barbastelles use linear features such as woodland edges and hedges.

The supplementary advice sets targets to restore foraging habitat and flightlines in the wider landscape. There are at least three breeding colonies of Barbastelle Bats in the New Forest National Park23 and recent records from the Nomansland area including the RSPB reserve. There may therefore be some movements or connectivity between the northern parts of the National Park and the Mottisfont Bats SAC. Any loss of hedgerows, linear strips of woodland, pockets of grassland and woodland within the landscape around 7km of the Mottisfont Bats SAC has the potential to undermine the conservation objectives.

The allocation SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford is around 8.7km from the Mottisfont Bats SAC (see Appendix 3) and while distant and outside the 7.5km impact zone, could be within the range used by foraging bats from Mottisfont. An early check of records from Hampshire Bat Group, Hampshire Biodiversity Information Centre and Wiltshire Biological Records Centre (see Map 8) show Barbastelle’s relatively close to the site. Aerial imagery shows that the site contains open grassland, woodland and linear woodland features. The site also lies relatively close to woodland areas within the New Forest SAC. There is clearly potential for Barbastelles to use the area, either for commuting or foraging. If they are using the area, risks from development would relate to loss of commuting routes and foraging habitat through direct destruction or from disturbance, e.g. through lighting.

The issue was identified in the HRA report that accompanied the Regulation 18 version of the Plan. Following the Regulation 18 HRA report, the National Park Authority commissioned a study to inform the approach taken in the Plan. This additional work24 involved a walk-over of the site by a bat expert with experience of Barbastelle, the collation of records and some fieldwork to ascertain whether Barbastelles were using the area. The results confirmed that Barbastelle were present on the site and were likely to be linked to the colony and maternity roost at the nearby Franchises Wood (RSPB). There are also suitable habitat linkages between Landford Corner and Mottisfont Bats SAC and it is therefore feasible that that the allocation could be within the home range of bats originating from the SAC.

Site enhancements to support the provision of Barbastelle has been recommended within the draft report. These enhancements and considerations include a 20m buffer of the site to preserve existing woodland and hedgerow features, preventing recreational access to these wooded areas, avoiding light pollution to the buffer zones and boundary features and ensuring that the overall development of the site is within the least impactful area. These have in turn been used to inform the policy wording of SP40 (criterion g):

further information will be required to demonstrate that potential impacts on the use of the surrounding area by Barbastelle Bats have been addressed. This will inform the appropriate assessment process and should include the results of a robust survey regime, appropriate mitigation, site enhancement measures and a monitoring protocol. Buffer areas of a minimum of 20 metres with no development or lighting will be required in relation to Heath Copse and Smallbrook Meadow.

The policy therefore ensures that appropriate project-level assessment is required alongside mitigation measures based on the recommendations within the report.

Conclusion: Mobile species and impacts to functionally-linked land

The HRA has identified likely significant effects with respect to Barbastelle Bats and the Mottisfont Bats SAC. Relevant policies are SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford; SP3 and SP29, which set overall housing numbers and include SP40. Barbastelle bats move widely in the landscape and 7km is typically used to define the area in which the species may roam from a roost to forage. SP40 is over 8km from Mottisfont SAC but there are some Barbastelle colonies within the New Forest and SP40 lies between these and Mottisfont. As such it may be that bats from Mottisfont SAC are moving between colonies and SP40 appears to include potential foraging and commuting habitat. Further evidence commissioned by the National Park Authority suggests that Barbastelle are using the site, potentially originating from a nearby colony within the New Forest. ~Due to the suitable habitats linkages between the Landford allocation, parts of the New Forest and Mottisfont it is reasonable to assume that the location is within the home range of bats that originate from the SAC. Policy wording ensures that appropriate project-level steps are taken to rule out adverse effects on the integrity of the site.


  1. https://www.newforestnpa.gov.uk/discover/wildlife/bats/barbastelle-bat/
  2. A review of Barbastelle Bats in the New Forest and Mottisfont Bats SAC Potential Impacts from Development at Landford Corner. Unpublished report by Ecological Consultancy Services Ltd. June 2026.

6. Appropriate assessment: Recreation

Policies identified in the screening

Likely significant effects were identified for the following policies from the screening:

  • SP3: Spatial Strategy (likely significant effects alone for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP29: New residential development in the National Park (likely significant effects alone for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC);
  • SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC);
  • SP34: Land at Knellers Lane, Ashurst (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC);
  • SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue, Lyndhurst (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC);
  • SP39: Land to west of Winsor Road, Winsor (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC);
  • SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP41: Land to the east of The Ridge, Redlynch (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP50: Allocation of land at Ringwood Road, Netley Marsh for Travelling Showpeople’s use (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC).

Policy SP11: Nature conservation sites of international importance was also screened in, with respect to both the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar as it is a bespoke policy intended to avoid or reduce harmful effects on a European site and sets out mitigation measures that need to be considered at appropriate assessment.

Overview of impact

New housing growth in the various villages around the New Forest, and any tourism development in the area, has the potential to result in more people visiting the countryside. Recreation can result in a number of impacts to the nature conservation interest of sites. These impacts are summarised in a number of general reviews (Liddle, 1997; Buckley, 2004; Lowen et al., 2008; Liley et al., 2010, 2019; Marzano and Dandy, 2012; Ryan, 2012).

The New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar

Impacts

Any changes in recreation use could lead to a number of impacts relevant to the European site qualifying features, including damage, contamination, disturbance and increased fire incidence (see Lake, Liley and Saunders, 2020; Liley et al., 2021 for review and discussion in context for the New Forest). Public access/disturbance is recognised by Natural England in the Site Improvement Plan for the Forest as a pressure on the site25.

Damage to the habitats for which the New Forest SAC is designated (and the habitats which in turn support the SPA/Ramsar features), can be realised through footfall (or wheels) on individual species, vegetation and soils. Issues relate to vegetation wear, soil compaction and erosion, i.e. largely unintentional consequences from the passage of people, pets and vehicles. These issues relate to plants and soils, but then changes in habitat extent (e.g. through the widening of footpaths and path erosion) and structure can also have consequences for a range of species and trampling can result in direct mortality for some fauna. In addition, damage can be deliberate, for example vandalism.

Vehicles parking on road verges are a long-standing concern as verge parking can lead to localised damage alongside some roads. Repeated wear will result in bare edges and a loss of vegetation, likely to be of particular concern for those verges with specialist flora such as Small Fleabane Pulicaria vulgaris (Lake, Liley and Saunders, 2020). Parking in gateways may have similar impacts and may also block legitimate access, with implications for emergency services (e.g. responding to fires) and commoning.

Nutrient levels in soil (particularly nitrogen and phosphorous) are important factors determining plant species composition. On heathland, dog fouling is the equivalent to applying a high level of fertilizer, resulting in a reduction in species richness and the presence of species typically associated with more ‘improved’ habitats. The impacts of dog fouling can often be seen in the form of grassy edges of paths on many heaths with high levels of access. This can be exacerbated by trampling, which has a lesser effect on species such as grasses, which grow from the base rather than the tip.

Dogs will typically defecate within 10 minutes of a walk starting, and as a consequence most (but not all) deposition tends to occur within around 400m of a site entrance (Taylor et al., 2005). In addition, most faeces are deposited close to the path, with a peak at approximately 1m from the path edge (Shaw, Lankey and Hollingham, 1995). Dogs will also typically urinate at the start of a walk, but they will also urinate at frequent intervals during the walk. The total volume deposited on sites may be surprisingly large (De Frenne et al., 2022; Harris, 2023).

Dogs are also being increasingly recognised as an issue with respect to water quality. The tick and flea treatments used on dogs are toxic to a range of invertebrates and have been widely reported from water bodies (e.g. Diepens et al., 2023), including a recent study from the New Forest26. Dogs swimming in ponds can also cause contamination through increased turbidity (Denton and Groome, 2017).

Besides dog fouling, other forms of contamination can include litter, fly tipping and the spread of non-native species, which can be spread on people’s clothing or pets’ fur. Studies have shown such vectors to distribute a range of non-native species and often over considerable distances (Wichmann et al., 2009; Anderson et al., 2015).

Fires can be caused accidentally from discarded cigarettes, by sparks from a campfire, BBQs (particularly the disposable BBQs that are placed on the ground), from fireworks, as a result of a controlled fire getting out of control, from discarded bottles in strong sunlight, from children playing with matches or similar, and even from deliberate arson. As such fire incidence can be directly linked to access. Climate change has meant that major fires tend to be more frequent and more severe (Jolly et al., 2015; Moffat and Gazzard, 2019) and heathland areas are particularly vulnerable. Impacts of fire on heathlands are reviewed by Underhill-Day (2005) and can include direct mortality, loss of habitat, loss of vegetation, damage to soils and vegetation change. Impacts can last many years.

Disturbance occurs where human activity influences an animal’s behaviour or survival. By far the majority of the literature (and there are thousands of studies) focuses on birds (for general reviews see Hockin et al., 1992; Hill et al., 1997; Brawn, Robinson and Thompson III, 2001; Lowen et al., 2008; Whitfield, Ruddock and Bullman, 2008; Showler, 2010; Steven, Pickering and Guy Castley, 2011). The presence of people in the countryside will influence wildlife in many ways. For many species, the people or their pets (e.g. dogs) are a potential threat and as such it is to be expected that the response will be to modify behaviour, for example fleeing.

Disturbance can have a range of different impacts potentially affecting distribution, breeding success and health. Impacts can be chronic, for example otherwise suitable nesting habitat being completely avoided (e.g. Liley and Sutherland, 2007) or more short-term in nature, for example birds becoming alert and then resuming the initial activity (e.g. Fernandez-Juricic, Jimenez and Lucas, 2001). For both nightjar and woodlark studies have shown recreation use affects the distribution of birds within sites, such that busy areas are avoided (Liley et al. 2006; Mallord et al. 2007; Lowe, Rogers & Durrant 2014). For Dartford warblers, breeding productivity is lower in territories where access levels are high (Murison et al. 2007), this is because disturbed birds nest later in the season. For nightjars there is also evidence of breeding success being lower on busier sites and busier parts of sites (Murison 2002). For woodlarks at least, there are clear population-level impacts as a result of the presence of people on the heaths (Mallord et al. 2007).

It is often difficult to separate different types of activities as at many sites multiple activities tend to overlap in space and time. Nonetheless, dogs are often identified as having a disproportionate effect (Lafferty, 2001; Thomas, Kvitek and Bretz, 2003; Banks and Bryant, 2007; Taylor, Green and Perrins, 2007; Liley and Fearnley, 2012; Cavalli et al., 2016; Gómez-Serrano, 2021; Harris, 2023); dogs are likely to be perceived as a greater threat, will actively chase birds and are able to track wildlife by smell.

High levels of access can also have issues for site management and take staff time and resources away from other management duties. Achieving effective conservation grazing on sites with high levels of access can be more challenging as recreational pressure can result in: worrying of animals by dogs, increased incidence of road accidents (although many may not be due to recreation), transfer of diseases, feeding and petting livestock and gateways etc may become blocked, limiting access for commoners. Worrying from dogs can also lead to animals behaving differently and becoming dangerous.

Visitors who consider the Forest first and foremost as a recreational destination may be less willing to take into account requirements dictated by land use or the wildlife of the Forest (such as keeping dogs under control). Parking charges could lead to the expectation of certain access rights, that certain areas should be primarily available for recreational pursuits or lead to a lack of willingness to see changes required for conservation or pastoral purposes, particularly changes that might result in a perceived loss of amenity.

As such it is clear there is the potential to undermine the conservation objectives for the New Forest in a range of ways. In particular, in terms of the extent and distribution of qualifying natural habitats and habitats of qualifying species and the structure and function of qualifying natural habitats or habitats of qualifying features.

Current visitor management

Recreation patterns and access are not static and change with time. The marked increase in visitors during the Covid pandemic (Caals, Panter and Liley, 2020) highlighted how quickly patterns can change and the unprecedented rise in visits to the Forest and was a preview of how visitor growth could soon manifest itself.

The National Park has established a Habitat Mitigation Scheme SPD27 which has been in place since 2012 and was revised in 2020 to address changing visitor pressure in the New Forest National Park. In addition, the recreation management strategy28 sets out a long-term vision for how recreation is managed and promoted in the New Forest National Park. The strategy, alongside the SPD seeks to balance the provision of recreation (and all the benefits this brings) with the negative impacts associated with overcrowding and damage to the nature conservation interests.

In addition, and more recently some changes have come into force which are relevant:

  • Public Space Protection Orders (PSPOs) have been introduced by New Forest District Council supported by Forestry England, the New Forest National Park Authority and the Verderers of the New Forest. The use of barbeques/fires within the Forest, and feeding and petting ponies or donkeys are all banned, with those failing to comply liable to a fixed penalty fine or prosecution.
  • Recreation permissions: a wide range of activities require permission from Forestry England, including all the activities that would normally not be allowed under the bylaws, such as organised races, charitable events, various training events; orienteering and weddings/blessings, amongst others. These are now covered under a protocol which sets out conditions, scale, locations and other details to ensure the cumulative effects of these permissions can be properly assessed (see Liley et al., 2021 for details and context).
  • Car park charges were introduced to all 129 Forestry England car parks across the New Forest in April 2026.
  • Parking on road verges across the Forest has received focus, forming one of the flagship projects for the National Park Authority29 and Forestry England has an ongoing programme in place where irresponsible parking in areas at risk of damage and erosion is deterred through the use of wooden bollards and ditches.

These changes mean general recreation use within the New Forest is better managed and particular impacts are addressed. The introduction of parking changes has been accompanied by clear messaging around the cost and difficulties in managing visitor use, helping to ensure visitors are more aware of the general issues. The strategic mitigation and implementation of the parking charges means there is now more staff presence out and about across the Forest.

Strategic mitigation

For the New Forest SPA/SAC/Ramsar issues around recreation have long been recognised and addressed by individual local authorities through dedicated, separate mitigation schemes. Detailed guidance for the National Park is set out in an SPD30 that was developed by the National Park Authority following liaison with Natural England and other relevant partners on the Authority’s Habitat Mitigation Steering Group. The key mitigation measures are:

  • Access management;
  • Alternative recreational greenspace sites and routes outside the designated sites;
  • Education, awareness and promotion;
  • Monitoring and research.

A joint commission by local planning authorities around the New Forest, including the National Park Authority, established a zone of influence, evidence for recreation patterns, links to local housing and evidence to support mitigation approaches (Lake, Liley and Saunders, 2020; Liley and Panter, 2020; Liley et al., 2020; Panter and Saunders, 2020). By addressing risks up front, strategic mitigation provides a proactive, cross-boundary, solution that ensures cumulative impacts of growth are taken into account and that the necessary resources and costs are identified.

Recreation pressure is complex, as the way visitors use a site can change with time and the distribution of the qualifying features can also change. Furthermore, to ensure effectiveness, mitigation needs to include a package of measures that work in an integrated way. For example, educating visitors, reinforcing messages with site-based staff, and providing the right infrastructure to meet visitor needs and influence visitor behaviour could all fit together as part of a mitigation package, but cannot be delivered in a piecemeal way, implemented by individual developments.

Collective funding is essential for on-site measures, and these can then in turn supported by the provision of the right alternative green infrastructure, i.e. a positive step to create more space for recreation and make a meaningful reduction in visits to the European sites. A strategic approach also ensures that mitigation can be secured in a way to maximise benefits for local communities and wildlife, ensuring a positive approach that provides for recreation use and ensures long-term protection for the European sites.

Climate change will impact the distribution of the qualifying features, exacerbate risks such as fire incidence, change recreation patterns and fundamentally change the coast and surrounding habitats. Recreation use will shift over time in response to trends, social media and a range of social factors and as such there is some complexity and inevitable uncertainty around the scale of future risk. Mitigation needs to be flexible to these changes and be able to respond appropriately.

The need for development to contribute to the strategic mitigation approach is secured in Policy SP11 and supporting text to the Policy provides further detail. With the strategic mitigation scheme fully operational and in place, all risks, alone or in-combination are addressed.

Solent and Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC

Coastal habitats and species are vulnerable to a range of recreation impacts, that could be triggered by additional recreation use linked to displacement. Reviews such as Saunders et al. (2000) and Lowen et al. (2008) provide context and background. Natural England’s site improvement plan for the Solent31 identifies public access and disturbance as a current threat.

Many of the impacts are similar to those already identified for the New Forest and Dorset Heaths (see above) and include:

  • Damage from trampling/wheels etc leading lead to vegetation wear, soil compaction and erosion (relevant to vegetated shingle, saltmarsh and foredune habitats in particular);
  • Contamination from dog fouling and contamination of water from dogs swimming (potentially relevant to saline lagoons);
  • Impacts of disturbance to birds a key concern for breeding terns (Liley, Saunders and Rush, 2023) and wintering waterbirds (Liley, Stillman and Fearnley, 2010; Liley et al., 2023) with mitigation for recreation (associated with new housing growth) estbalished through Bird Aware Solent;
  • Increased fire risk (potentially a low risk, but can be relevant to reed beds);
  • Impacts to management, such as challenges with livestock grazing.

The above have the potential to undermine the conservation objectives of the Solent Maritime SAC with respect to distribution of the feature, extent and structure and function. For the Solent and Southampton Water SPA the supplementary conservation advice sets targets for the qualifying features to reduce the frequency, duration and/or intensity of disturbance.

Strategic mitigation

For the Solent, strategic mitigation has been long established through the Solent Recreation Mitigation Partnership and delivered by Bird Aware Solent32. The scheme was established in 2017 (Bird Aware Solent, 2017), underpinned by a large body of evidence relating to visitor use and bird disturbance (Stillman et al., 2009, 2012; Fearnley, Clarke and Liley, 2010, 2011; Liley, Stillman and Fearnley, 2010; ABP Marine Environmental Research Ltd., 2012) which has since been regularly reviewed and updated (Liley et al., 2023; Bird Aware Solent, 2024), with the update extending the strategy to cover summer breeding birds, (see Liley, Saunders and Rush, 2023). The scheme covers the Solent and Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar as well as Chichester & Langstone Harbours SPA/Ramsar and Portsmouth Harbour SPA/Ramsar. The partnership comprises all 15 local planning authorities whose areas fall within 5.6km of the European sites and the current strategy has been devised to mitigate housing across these authorities that comes forward in the period through to 2050.

The Solent mitigation scheme only relates to birds and does not have specific mitigation that addresses recreation impacts to habitats (i.e. features of the Solent Maritime SAC). Nonetheless, there is clearly overlap as measures to influence visitor behaviour will also be relevant to habitats and the breeding bird interest also overlaps with the habitat features of the SAC (vegetated shingle, saltmarsh etc). Areas where habitat damage might be a concern (e.g. from trampling or dog fouling) are also areas important for birds and will be covered through the mitigation. Given the scale of growth proposed in the Plan and its dispersed nature (meaning recreation use is also likely to be dispersed around the coast), it should therefore be sufficient to rely on the Bird Aware strategy to address impacts to the Solent Maritime SAC.

As with the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar, the need for development to contribute to the strategic mitigation approach is secured in Policy SP11 and supporting text to the Policy provides further detail. With the strategic mitigation scheme fully operational and in place, all risks, alone or in-combination are addressed.

Conclusions: Recreation

Strategic mitigation schemes provide the means to rule out adverse effects from recreation and ensure cumulative impacts are addressed. Compliance with these schemes is secured through Policy SP11. The level of growth within the Plan and the locations for that growth are such that the mitigation is sufficient and no additional mitigation is likely to be needed.


  1. https://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/publication/5174614971908096
  2. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-68400630
  3. https://www.newforestnpa.gov.uk/document/revised-habitat-mitigation-scheme-spd/
  4. https://www.newforestnpa.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/RMS-TOWEB.pdf
  5. https://www.newforestnpa.gov.uk/protecting/flagship-projects/higher-level-stewardship-scheme/verges/
  6. https://www.newforestnpa.gov.uk/app/uploads/2020/07/Revised-Habitat-Mitigation-Scheme-SPD-.pdf
  7. https://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/publication/4692013588938752
  8. https://birdaware.org/solent/

7. Appropriate assessment: Water quality

Policies identified in the screening

Likely significant effects were identified for the following policies from the screening, as they promote development within a nutrient catchment where some form of nutrient neutrality is required:

  • SP3: Spatial Strategy (likely significant effects alone for the Solent Maritime SAC, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the River Avon SAC)
  • SP29: New residential development in the National Park (likely significant effects alone for the Solent Maritime SAC, the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the River Avon SAC)
  • SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP34: Land at Knellers Lane, Ashurst (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP36: Land at Calpe Avenue, Lyndhurst (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP39: Land to west of Winsor Road, Winsor (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP40: Land to the south of Hamptworth Road, Landford (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP41: Land to the east of The Ridge, Redlynch (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent Maritime SAC and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar).
  • SP50: Allocation of land at Ringwood Road, Netley Marsh for Travelling Showpeople’s use (likely significant effects in-combination for the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC).

In addition, SP3, SP29 and the following allocations were screened in alone for impacts to nearby European sites as a result of run-off and the potential for contamination:

  • SP5 Land to north of Fawley Waterside (Solent Maritime SAC, Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar);
  • SP33: Land at Ashurst Hospital (the New Forest SAC and the New Forest Ramsar);
  • SP38: Land to west of Brighton Road, Sway (the New Forest SAC and the New Forest Ramsar).

Also relevant is Policy SP11: Nature conservation sites of international importance which sets out mitigation requirements for nutrient neutrality.

Wastewater and nutrient neutrality

Wastewater or sewage can be very damaging to water bodies as it can contain large amounts of nutrients (such as phosphorus and nitrates), ammonia, bacteria, harmful chemicals and other damaging substances. Issues arise where sewage treatment technology to adequately reduce levels of phosphorus and harmful chemicals is not in place, where leakages occur from privately owned septic tanks and, in wet weather, storm overflows can discharge untreated sewage. Poorly installed domestic washing machines and even washing cars at home can, in places, also add to the pollution load. Outcomes can include increased turbidity, algal blooms, reduced dissolved oxygen and an overall increase in the nutrient status of receiving waterbodies. Simply, increases in housing increase pressure on the sewage network and the volume of wastewater.

The pollution of inland and coastal waters has received greater recognition in recent years and the significance of such potential impacts and the need to mitigate has been given emphasis by Natural England’s advice to local planning authorities. Natural England have advised that new development affecting vulnerable water bodies must achieve ‘nutrient neutrality’, i.e. avoid any net increase in nitrate and/or phosphate pollution. Whilst this relates primarily to the disposal of foul water, run-off from hard surfaces can also be a factor. This reflects contemporary case law (the Dutch case) which makes clear that where water quality targets of European sites are not being met, further inputs of pollutants should not be allowed.

Both the River Avon SAC and the Solent are covered by Natural England’s advice and a need for nutrient neutrality. Any development involving the potential for overnight accommodation within the National Park will therefore need to ensure nutrient neutrality.

For the avoidance of any doubt, while the Avon catchment for nutrients does overlap with the National Park boundary, the Plan does not include any allocations within the Avon catchment and none of the Defined Villages are within the catchment. As such risks for the River Avon SAC will only relate to windfall that is outside the Defined Villages and as such any growth will be very low, if any.

Advice, further links and details on mitigation requirements are set out on the National Park website33. These include reference to the updated national guidance and tools for addressing nutrient neutrality, issued by National Government in 2024. These reflect upgrades to certain wastewater treatment works required by 2030 under the provisions of the Levelling Up & Regeneration Act 2023.

Policy SP11 sets the requirement that applications for net dwellings and other forms of overnight accommodation will be expected to demonstrate nutrient neutrality. The Policy also covers other forms of new development. This ensures all development is mitigated.

It is the responsibility of the applicant/developer to find suitable and sufficient nutrient mitigation solutions. The Solent Mitigation Partnership website34 provides a means for developers to buy credits and also provides background information and context. In addition, the Partnership for South Hampshire’s website35 also provides details of other available mitigation sites. The Solent Mitigation Partnership ensures strategic and efficient delivery of mitigation and ensures there is sufficient mitigation options in the pipeline to accommodate growth.

The Solent Mitigation Partnership36 has reviewed the nutrient budget for the Local Plan and checked that sufficient mitigation is available. Their nutrient demand calculation (Table 3) includes allocations in the Plan and estimated windfall that is predicated to come forward. This gives an overall picture of the potential nutrient demand related to housing development for the relevant catchments. Nutrients associated with new development within the New Forest National Park Authority could enter the Solent via the New Forest Rivers or the Test (‘Test & Itchen sub-catchment), and for these areas it is necessary to achieve nutrient neutrality in relation to Nitrogen only.

Table 3: Nutrient need associated with the Plan

Figures are for total nitrogen (‘TN’). Figures provided by the Solent Mitigation Partnership. Columns reflect the different sub-catchments for the Solent area. The Test and Itchen are grouped into the same sub-catchment, however it should be noted the New Forest NPA is only relevant to the Test.

0-5 years (Kg/TN/Yr) 5+ years
New Forest Rivers Test & Itchen New Forest Rivers Test & Itchen
Allocations 131.5 17 29.2Kg 394
Windfall 81.8 219.3 163.6 227.2
Total 213.3 236.3 163.6 621.2
Overall Total 1234.4

Based on the above figures, the Solent Mitigation Partnership have advised that sufficient mitigation is available for the first 5 years of the Plan period. Furthermore, the current rate of mitigation schemes coming online is expected to continue and be able to meet future demand. This is informed by the investment strategy of the Solent Mitigation Partnership who received funding from MHCLG to create large-scale nutrient mitigation sites to enable housing delivery. Beyond the next 5 to 10 years, it is likely that mitigation will be supplemented by enhancements to regional WwTW. Mandated through the Levelling Up and Regeneration Act (LURA) 2023.

As such, the Solent Mitigation Partnership conclude that sufficient nutrient mitigation credits will be available to satisfy the development needs of the NFNPA across all of the Local Plan allocations. The schemes can be relied on to mitigate the levels of growth proposed, mitigation is achievable, deliverable and can be secured for the duration of the impact. As development will be nutrient neutral there can be no scope for residual effects and no risk of cumulative impact.

Individual allocations and issues with run-off and drainage

Likely significant effects were identified for two allocations (SP5 and SP38) alone, due to their proximity to European sites. For these sites there are specific local risks with run-off and contamination linked to surface water flows from the allocation site onto the European site, including from construction. SP3 and SP29 were similarly identified as triggering likely significant effects, as these policies include the specific allocations above and also set overall levels of growth that includes windfall and unallocated sites.

These risks can only be fully assessed at project level and suitable mitigation, where necessary, secured through design. Sustainable Urban Drainage (SUDS), layout, landscaping and boundary works will determine the degree of risk.

Policy wording for SP33 and SP38 identifies the need for mitigation for urban edge effects, landscaping and boundary treatments.

The supporting text for SP5 at Fawley highlights the site was previously a Ministry of Defence fuel storage facility, which was decommissioned and largely dismantled during the 1960s. It has subsequently operated as a waste recycling and transfer facility. More recently, the site has been subject to unauthorised importation and deposition of household waste beyond the scope of the permitted waste recovery and transfer activities. Despite limited historic remediation, waste remains both above and below ground, presenting potential risks to soils and groundwater. Policy SP5 requires a masterplan to ensure redevelopment fully mitigates its impacts, the policy specifically identifies that development proposals should explore opportunities to enhance and restore the watercourse along the eastern boundary and states that the development will deliver comprehensive remediation of the whole site.

These site-specific requirements, combined with the blanket protection afforded by SP11 (which will cover unallocated windfall sites) ensure adverse effects on integrity should be fully mitigated and impacts avoided. Policy SP7: Safeguarding and improving water resources, while not specifically mitigating impact in relation to European sites, also is clear that development will not be permitted if it would risk harm to the quality of water resources. The policy states that Sustainable Urban Drainage Systems (SuDS) should be integrated into development and that surface water from new development will not be permitted to discharge into the foul or combined sewer network, to minimise the risk of sewer flooding.

Conclusions: Water Quality

Nutrient neutrality is required for all new net dwellings and other forms of overnight accommodation (Policy SP11) and this ensures impacts from wastewater and nutrient enrichment are addressed for all relevant sites (River Avon SAC and Solent Coast European sites). There is no scope for residual effects or cumulative impact. Direct run-off (surface water) is a potential concern for a small number of allocations in proximity to European sites. Specific policy wording for these allocations ensures risks will be addressed in the detailed design of the sites and their layout. Policy SP11 ensures any windfall sites are subject to HRA and project level assessment – once details are available – to ensure compliance with the Habitats Regulations.


  1. https://www.newforestnpa.gov.uk/planning/guidance-on-applying/supporting-documents/nutrient-mitigation/
  2. https://solentmitigationpartnership.co.uk/buy-credits/
  3. https://www.push.gov.uk/work/mitigation-schemes-available-to-developers/
  4. Document and figures produced by Solent Mitigation Partnership for the NFNPA in July 2026

8. Appropriate assessment: Water quantity

Policies identified in the screening

Likely significant effects were identified for the following policies from the screening:

  • SP3: Spatial Strategy (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC, the New Forest Ramsar, the River Itchen SAC and River Avon SAC).
  • SP29: New residential development in the National Park (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC, the New Forest Ramsar, the River Itchen SAC and River Avon SAC).

All new allocations and those yet to be granted planning permission were also screened in, in-combination, with respect to water quantity and the same European sites.

Also relevant is Policy SP7 which requires new homes to meet either a water efficiency standard of 100 litres maximum daily allowable usage per person, or any future national standards, whichever is lower. While this is not mitigation and as such not screened in for appropriate assessment, it is relevant in that it will make a small contribution to reducing water demand from new development.

Overview of impact

Where European sites are dependent on water to support the qualifying features then changes in the water levels or flow have the potential to undermine the conservation objectives. Impacts could result from increased abstraction or changes to surface water flow. Increasing the extent of impermeable surfaces can result in changes to the volume and speed of run-off, changing flow dynamics. Combined sewage outflows will discharge excess water into watercourses, with further impacts to flow.

River Basin Management Plans and role of the Environment Agency

It is the role of the Environment Agency to make sure that abstraction is sustainable and does not damage the environment. Water abstraction is managed through a licensing system originally introduced by the Water Resources Act 1963.

The Environment Agency oversees the publication of River Basin Management Plans (RBMPs). These set the legally binding locally specific environmental objectives that underpin water regulation. They set out how the management of water bodies will be undertaken, the roles of relevant bodies and the steps undertaken to ensure environmental targets are met.

The most recent RBMPs were updated in 2022, with separate plans covering the South-west37 (which includes the catchment of the River Avon) and the South-east of England38. The two plans commit the Environment Agency to assess all licence applications and only issue licences that adequately protect and improve the environment; where necessary each should be subject to an individual HRA. The Agency will only grant replacement licences where the abstraction is environmentally sustainable, and abstractors can demonstrate they have a continued need for the water, and it will be used efficiently. In addition, for existing licences, the Agency will prioritise actions to protect and improve European sites and address the most seriously damaging abstractions during this plan period. All abstractors in surface water and groundwater bodies where serious damage is occurring or could occur without action should expect that their licences will be constrained over the next six years. Both relevant RBMPs were subject to HRA39 neither of which identified any likely significant effects on any European sites, alone or in combination with other plans or projects.

Water companies

The Water Act 2003 introduced a legal requirement into the Water Industry Act 1991 for water companies to prepare, publish and maintain Water Resources Management Plans (WRMPs). These take place on a five-year cycle and set out how public water supply will be maintained over a minimum of 25 years in a way that is economically, socially and environmentally sustainable.

South West Water cover the Bournemouth Water Resource Zone, which extends as far east as Lymington and includes parts of the National Park area. The most recent WRMP (dated 2024) was subject to HRA40, which concluded that adverse effects can be avoided or fully mitigated for all but one of the options included in the WRMP and all European sites. The exception was one of the options included in the Plan (a new strategic reservoir, Cheddar 2, which is unlikely to be relevant to the New Forest area). The WRMP simply highlights that further assessment of this will be required during option development, as insufficient details are available at the present time.

Southern Water is responsible for other parts of the National Park area. Southern Water, in their representations at Regulation 18, have confirmed in all instances where they are the water supplier for a given allocation, that there is capacity to accommodate the number of dwellings at each, in terms of water supply.

Southern Water’s WRMP41 states that much of the water supplied in the area around the New Forest comes from underground sources, the Test and the Itchen. The HRA42 concluded that for virtually all of the WRMP options, there were no adverse effects on any European sites, however it did also recognise that there were some residual uncertainties associated with some options within the WRMP. In these instances, the WRMP does provide substantial time for any uncertainties linked to these options to be resolved and (if necessary) the option set aside and replaced in future WRMP cycles.

The issues in terms of abstraction are more strategic in nature compared to some other impact pathways and relate to the overall levels of growth and whether these can be supported without harm to European sites (including any potential new infrastructure that might be required). According to government guidance43, the National Park Authority can defer to the HRAs for the relevant WRMPs and rely on its conclusions if there is no information or evidence that may lead to a different conclusion, if the previous assessment is relevant, thorough and correct, the conclusions are rigorous and there is no new case law that might be relevant.

Conclusions: Water quantity

The provision of domestic water supplies to new development and the implications for European sites tend to be strategic in nature compared to some other impact pathways and relate to the overall levels of growth and whether these can be supported (including any potential new infrastructure that might be required), without harm. Water Resource Management Plans (WRMP) for the relevant water companies provide reassurance that adequate resources are available and mitigation options are available that will not lead to adverse effects on integrity for any European site. The National Park Authority can defer to the WRMP HRAs and rely on their conclusions, and as such impacts can be ruled out for water quantity.


  1. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/south-west-river-basin-district-river-basin-management-plan-updated-2022
  2. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/south-east-river-basin-district-river-basin-management-plan-updated-2022
  3. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/635246fae90e07768c1a73a2/South_west_river_basin_management_plan_2022_HRA.pdf and https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/635246848fa8f554c876f7ea/South_east_river_basin_management_plan_2022_HRA.pdf
  4. https://www.bournemouthwater.co.uk/siteassets/documents/about-us/wrmp/sww-dwrmp24-appendix-7-sea-report-dec23-annex-h-hra.pdf
  5. https://www.southernwater.co.uk/media/2p5o0k0c/technical-report.pdf
  6. https://www.southernwater.co.uk/media/b45jc3w1/annex-18-habitat-regulations-assessment-report.pdf
  7. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/habitats-regulations-assessments-protecting-a-european-site#make-decision-making-quicker

9. Appropriate assessment: Air quality

Policies identified in the screening

Likely significant effects were identified for the following policies from the screening:

  • SP3: Spatial Strategy (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar).
  • SP29: New residential development in the National Park (likely significant effects in-combination for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar).

All new allocations and those yet to be granted planning permission were also screened in, in-combination, with respect to air quality and the same European sites.

Overview of impact

The primary impact mechanism for air quality relates to increased traffic emissions. Development is typically associated with increased traffic and emissions which can increase the airborne concentration of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and ammonia (NH3), and the subsequent rate of nitrogen deposition from the atmosphere. This can lead to the nutrient enrichment and acidification of soils, encouraging more tolerant ruderal species at the expense of sensitive plant, lower plant and invertebrate communities. In high concentrations, ammonia can result in direct toxic effects on vegetation, a factor which may also be true of NOx. Larger animals, such as small mammals and birds are considered immune to direct effects but can be vulnerable to change in their supporting habitats. Furthermore, it can exacerbate the effects of other factors such as climate change or pathogens, for example.

Air quality impacts decline with distance away from the road, and it is therefore only where a road goes through a European site or is within 200m of the site, that impacts are likely (see Natural England, 2018 and CIEEM, 2021 for background and discussion on the application of the 200m distance). The New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar is bisected by numerous roads (see Map 7), which include the A36 and M27.

Findings from previous HRA work and more recent surveys

The HRA work undertaken for the existing adopted New Forest National Park Authority Local Plan, and New Forest District Council’s Local Plan identified uncertainties around the potential for in-combination effects of traffic and impacts to the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar. The two Local Plans together proposed around 11,000 new homes for the period 2016-2036. The HRAs were able to conclude no adverse effects on integrity on the basis of commitments in the Local Plans to monitor and, if necessary, mitigate adverse effects on the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar. A mitigation strategy (Kite et al., 2018) was produced with a detailed regime to monitor air quality concentrations and habitat condition at representative locations.

The results from the initial monitoring (in 2021) are summarised by Atkins (2022) and more recent monitoring results (data collected in 2024) by AtkinsRealis (2026). Future monitoring is scheduled to be carried out at the same fixed-point monitoring locations in 2027. Monitoring has included air quality and vegetation monitoring at carefully selected locations. Data are collected at different distances from the road, with the expectation that if traffic is a key driver for air quality effects, impacts will decline with distance from the road.

The monitoring results show that:

  • NOx concentrations decrease with distance from the road but remain below the critical level of NOx at all monitoring locations.
  • NH3 average concentrations were below the critical level of NH3 (based on the more reliable ALPHA samplers) and there was no trend in distance from the road.
  • N deposition rates exceeded the critical load at all monitoring locations and decreased with distance from the road.

The 2026 monitoring report states that: “Given the results of the air quality monitoring from both the 2021 and 2024 surveys, it is therefore likely that, if traffic emissions are currently contributing to adverse effects on the New Forest SAC, N dep would be the key factor. That is not to say that traffic emissions are not contributing to any adverse effects associated with the exceedance of NH3 levels, rather that other sources of that pollutant (such as agriculture) are likely to be playing a more important role.”

The habitat monitoring did not indicate any impacts of traffic emissions on the sampled heathland or woodland qualifying features of the SAC. The only significant trends that were observed in relation to distance from the road were more likely to be linked to other influences such as the intensity of grazing or past management.

The report concluded that the air quality and habitat monitoring study provide no indication that the New Forest SAC is being adversely affected by local traffic emissions 45m or more from the road.

Impact of proposed level of growth within the Plan

The National Park Authority has not commissioned a transport assessment or commissioned traffic modelling, due to the small scale of planned new development proposed (around 950 net dwellings to 2043).

As such, there is no prediction of traffic increase along specific roads. The dispersed nature of the allocations within the Plan and the specific locations mean many allocations will have limited implications for traffic flows (see Map 9 for context). For example, SP34: Land at Keller’s Lane, Ashurst; SP39: Land to the West of Winsor Road, Winsor and SP5: Land to the north of Fawley Waterside are in locations where traffic is likely to flow along the eastern side of the National Park Authority area, towards Totton and away from the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar. Similarly, SP38: Land to the west of Brighton Road, Sway is in the south-west of the National Park Authority, on the edge of the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and traffic movements are likely to be into Sway and towards Christchurch, thereby away from the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar.

Typical traffic flows associated with rural dwellings could in in the region of 6-8 two-way trips per dwelling per day, and therefore 950 dwellings could possibly generate up to 7,600 daily trips. These will be spread across a range of roads, many of which will not cross the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar. There is a 40mph speed limit for many of the roads that are relevant and slow traffic flows (e.g. tourism related) will tend to deflect use to roads that are outside the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar.

This low level of traffic increase needs to be considered in light of the increasing uptake of electric vehicles with zero emissions, good rail connections and increasing focus away from car dependency44.

As such it is not possible to derive predictions for future vehicle use associated with the Plan, however risks are likely to be low, dispersed across multiple roads and to decrease with time.

Mitigation

The National Park Authority will continue with the approach in the current adopted plan of monitoring and undertaking mitigation, as triggered by monitoring results. This approach ensures that there is a means of addressing the uncertainty around changing patterns of vehicle use and the impacts of growth.

The National Park Authority will work with neighbouring authorities, in particular New Forest District Council, where the much more significant levels of growth proposed and scale mean that HRA work has addressed the in-combination effects of increased road transport on the strategic road network.

SP11 demonstrates a commitment to monitor the impacts from increased road transport and their associated emissions across the New Forest designated sites:

The National Park Authority will continue to work with partners to monitor the in-combination effects of increased road traffic and the associated emissions on the New Forest’s designated sites. If the monitoring results indicate potential impacts on site integrity avoidance and mitigation measures will be required for development to be permitted. This may include a proportionate contribution from new development to support the implementation of measures.

The Plan includes a monitoring indicator (under Objective 1 in Section 11) relating to air quality, working with neighbouring authorities to monitor changes in air quality on the New Forest’s internationally designated sites. The monitoring will establish the trend of movement in critical levels of pollutants and work with partners on a strategic mitigation package if such an approach is necessary.

Conclusions: Air Quality and the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar

Risks from air pollution associated with increased traffic are likely to be low, dispersed across multiple roads and to decrease with time. The National Park Authority has not commissioned a transport assessment or commissioned traffic modelling, and it is not possible to derive predictions for future vehicle use associated with the Plan. However, the National Park Authority can defer to HRA work undertaken by neighbouring authorities which includes the in-combination effect of development within the New Forest National Park.

The National Park Authority will continue working with neighbouring authorities to monitor changes in air quality on the New Forest’s internationally designated sites and changes in habitat and vegetation alongside roads. This approach was established as part of the assessment work for the previous local plan. If the monitoring results provide any indication that the New Forest SAC is being adversely affected by local traffic emissions, this will then trigger the need for mitigation, in line with the current mitigation plan.

The approach is secured in policy SP11 and secured with neighbouring authorities.


  1. See for example the Hampshire County Council Local Transport Plan 4 https://documents.hants.gov.uk/transport/hampshire-local-transport-plan-4-2024.pdf

10. Integrity test

The New Forest National Park Local Plan Review 2024 – 2043 Proposed Submission Draft Local Plan (Regulation 19) has been subjected to an appropriate assessment according to the statutory provisions laid out in the Habitats Regulations 2017, as amended.

Likely significant effects were identified for general urban effects and the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar. There are no allocations relating to C3 residential use within 400m of the SPA/SAC/Ramsar, in line with the current (adopted plan). This approach ensures any growth within 400m is very limited. There are three allocations within 400m of the SAC/SPA/Ramsar for C2 care home use. The type of use, combined with policy wording to ensure mitigation for urban edge effects (e.g. boundary treatments) mean adverse effects on integrity can be ruled out for these three allocations, one of which has been granted outline planning permission. The type of use, lack of SPA/Ramsar interest, habitat (predominantly wooded) and location mean risks are very low. Any unallocated windfall sites that come forward within 400m will need to be subject to appropriate assessment and the need for this is set out in Policy SP11. Supporting text to SP11 (para 6.14) sets out the need for appropriate assessment in relation to urban edge effects. All risks are therefore addressed and adverse effects on integrity can be ruled out from the Plan alone. There is no scope for in-combination effects given that the New Forest National Park Authority boundary encompasses almost all areas within 400m.

Likely significant effects were also identified in relation to general urban effects and the Solent Maritime SAC & the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar. A single allocation (SP5) for employment use, is within 400m of Solent Maritime SAC & the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar. Policy SP11 provides general protective wording and the need for appropriate assessment. Specific policy wording for SP5 ensures a masterplan will be produced that sets out all necessary mitigation alongside the layout, planting etc. This ensures development will only proceed subject to further checks at project level, once the full details are available and necessary design elements complete. As such this wording eliminates risks and allows, at a Plan level, a conclusion of no adverse effects on integrity, alone or in-combination.

The HRA has identified likely significant effects with respect to a particular allocation (SP40) and Barbastelle Bats associated with the Mottisfont Bats SAC. These bats move widely in the landscape and while the allocation is distant (and outside the distance any impact may be normally assumed), there are known roosts outside the SAC in relative proximity. The issue was identified as part of the Regulation 18 HRA. Given the location and characteristics of the allocation site, the National Park Authority subsequently commissioned a barbastelle expert to check the allocation site, collate local records and identify potential next steps. The work indicated that Barbastelle are present at the site and a number of recommendations were made regarding mitigation measures that might be necessary (along with further, more detailed survey work). The mitigation requirements have in turn been fed through into policy, which ensures the development will be subject to project level HRA and identifies the mitigation measures likely to be necessary. As such, the adverse effects on integrity are ruled out alone and there is no risk of cumulative effects given the specific nature and location of the allocation.

Likely significant effects from recreation were identified for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar and the Solent & Southampton Water SPA/Ramsar and the Solent Maritime SAC. Policy SP11 secures mitigation through the strategic mitigation schemes, that have been designed to address the scale of growth across multiple local authorities within defined zones of influence. The schemes address the total growth within the Plan and also the cumulative effects with neighbouring authorities. As such adverse effects on integrity can be ruled out from recreation for the New Forest and Solent SPA/Ramsar sites, alone or in-combination.

The Solent mitigation scheme only relates to birds and does not have specific mitigation that addresses recreation impacts to habitats (i.e. features of the Solent Maritime SAC). Nonetheless, there is clearly overlap as measures to influence visitor behaviour will also be relevant to habitats and the breeding bird interest also overlaps with the habitat features of the SAC. Given the scale of growth proposed in the Plan and the relatively dispersed nature of that growth, it is reasonable to rely on the Bird Aware strategy to address impacts to the Solent Maritime SAC.

Nutrient neutrality is required within the Plan (in Policy SP11) for all new net dwellings and other forms of overnight accommodation, and this ensures impacts from wastewater and nutrient enrichment are addressed for all relevant sites (River Avon SAC and Solent Coast European sites). With any such development being nutrient neutral, there can be no cumulative effects and adverse effects on integrity from wastewater can be ruled out alone or in-combination.

Direct run-off (surface water) was identified as a potential concern for a small number of allocations in proximity to European sites. Specific policy wording for each of these ensures development will only proceed subject to further checks at project level, once the full details are available and necessary design elements complete. Policy SP11 ensures any windfall sites are subject to HRA and project level assessment, once details are available to allow an assessment to be undertaken. As such adverse effects on integrity at Plan level can be ruled out, alone or in-combination.

WRMPs for the relevant water companies provide reassurance that adequate resources are available and mitigation options are available that will not lead to adverse effects on integrity for any European site. The National Park Authority can defer to the WRMP HRAs and rely on their conclusions, and as such impacts can be ruled out for water quantity.

Air quality was screened in for the Plan in-combination, for the New Forest SAC/SPA/Ramsar. Risks relate to increased traffic and the cumulative effects of traffic across the National Park and neighbouring authorities. The National Park Authority has not commissioned a transport assessment or commissioned traffic modelling, and it is not possible to derive predictions for future vehicle use associated with the Plan. Risks from air pollution associated with increased traffic are likely to be low, dispersed across multiple roads and to decrease with time. As such, the National Park Authority has committed in policy SP11 to work with partners and continue to monitor in-combination effects of increased road traffic and the associated emissions on the New Forest’s designated sites. Policy SP11 is clear that If the monitoring results indicate potential impacts on site integrity, avoidance and mitigation measures will be required for development to be permitted. This ensures a ‘watching brief’ and that development will not come forward if monitoring identifies risk. This approach relates to the cumulative, in-combination effects of traffic and therefore means adverse effects on integrity can be ruled out from air quality, alone or in-combination.

References

ABP Marine Environmental Research Ltd. (2012) Scientific Peer Review of Outputs of the Solent Disturbance and Mitigation Project. R.2051.

Anderson, L.G. et al. (2015) ‘The Role of Tourism and Recreation in the Spread of Non-Native Species: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis’, PLOS ONE. Edited by R. Britton, 10(10), p. e0140833. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0140833.

Atkins Ltd. (2022) New Forest Habitat and Air Quality Monitoring. Report by Atkins for New Forest District Council and the New Forest National Park Authority.

AtkinsRealis (2026) New Forest Habitat and Air Quality Monitoring Year 2 Interim Report. Report for New Forest District Council and the New Forest National Park Authority.

Banks, P.B. and Bryant, J.V. (2007) ‘Four-legged friend of foe? Dog-walking displaces native birds from natural areas’, Biology Letters, 3(6), pp. 611–613.

Beveridge, L. et al. (2024) Compilation and Review of Evidence Leading to SANG and SAMM Provision. RP04518. Report by Lepus for Natural England.

Bird Aware Solent (2017) Solent Recreation Mitigation Strategy. Available at: http://www.birdaware.org/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=29372&p=0.

Bird Aware Solent (2024) ‘Bird Aware Solent Revised Strategy’.

Brawn, J., Robinson, S. and Thompson III, F. (2001) ‘The role of disturbance in the ecology and conservation of birds’, Annual review of Ecology and Systematics, 32(2001), pp. 251–276.

Buckley, R. (2004) Environmental impacts of Ecotourism. Wallingford, Oxfordshire: CABI.

Caals, Z., Panter, C. and Liley, D. (2020) Epping Forest Covid-19 Visitor Survey: Online Questionnaire. Unpublished report for City of London 605. Footprint Ecology / City of London.

Cavalli, M. et al. (2016) ‘Differential risk perception of rural and urban Burrowing Owls exposed to humans and dogs’, Behavioural Processes, 124, pp. 60–65. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.beproc.2015.12.006.

Chapman, C. and Kite, B. (2021) Guidance on decision-making thresholds for air pollution. JNCC Report 696. Peterborough: JNCC.

CIEEM (2021) Advice on Ecological Assessment of Air Quality Impacts. Chartered Institute of Ecology and Environmental Management.

De Frenne, P. et al. (2022) ‘Nutrient fertilization by dogs in peri-urban ecosystems’, Ecological Solutions and Evidence, 3(1), p. e12128. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1002/2688-8319.12128.

Denton, J. and Groome, G. (2017) ‘Dogs and ponds: a case study from Headley Heath’, Conservation Land Management